Hori Y, Koike Y, Ohyama G, Otsu S Y, Abe K
Department of Otolaryngology, The University of Tokushima, School of Medicine, Japan.
Acta Otolaryngol Suppl. 1996;523:248-51.
Changes in the articulation of 5 Japanese vowels before and after tonsillectomy were compared using the formants as indicators. Data from 40 patients were analyzed and those from 10 healthy volunteers were adopted as control. The comparison of formant frequencies before and 1 month after operation revealed that F1, F2 and F4 remained within the range of intra-individual fluctuations in most cases. F3, however, exceedingly decreased in many cases, and the decrease was particularly marked for /o/. No evident change was observed as to formant bandwidth. The larger the tonsil was, the more changes were seen in the formant frequency. The evaluation according to Mackenzie's classification was found to be unsatisfactory. Observing the postoperative changes over time, it is suggested that the altered vocal tract slowly compensates by means of the surrounding tissues. From the acoustic evaluation, the changes in the articulation due to surgery were considered to be negligible in clinical practice, although in professional vocalists it seemed to be a problem that cannot be disregarded.
以共振峰为指标,比较了40例患者扁桃体切除术前、后5个日语元音发音的变化,并选取10名健康志愿者的数据作为对照进行分析。手术前和术后1个月共振峰频率的比较显示,在大多数情况下,F1、F2和F4仍在个体波动范围内。然而,F3在许多情况下显著下降,其中/o/的下降尤为明显。共振峰带宽未观察到明显变化。扁桃体越大,共振峰频率变化越大。根据麦肯齐分类法进行的评估并不理想。观察术后随时间的变化情况,提示手术改变的声道可通过周围组织缓慢代偿。从声学评估来看,尽管对于专业歌手而言这似乎是一个不可忽视的问题,但在临床实践中,手术引起的发音变化被认为可忽略不计。