Persson B
Department of Psychology, University of Lund, Sweden.
Headache. 1997 Mar;37(3):159-68. doi: 10.1046/j.1526-4610.1997.3703159.x.
The aim of the study was to compare adult migraine discordant full siblings in terms of personality and psychosocial environment during childhood. The study, involving 30 sibling pairs and use of various personality instruments (Eysenck Personality Inventory [EPI], Color Word Test [CWT], Visual Aftereffects [VAE], Meta Contrast Technique [MCT], Cesarec-Marke Personality Schedule), showed the migraineurs scored significantly higher on neuroticism [EPI], also called emotional stress or trait anxiety; to be more sensitive (MCT); and to display signs of greater anxiety (VAE, CWT). Furthermore, migraineurs tended to report greater scarcity of friends during childhood and less verbal, as well as, nonverbal encouragement from their parents, than their migraine-free siblings. Neuroticism was found to correlate significantly with migraine, but not with headache frequency or severity in the migraine group. It is argued that, due to the high neuroticism of some migraineurs, psychotherapy should be considered as an alternative to other prophylactic treatments such as use of beta-adrenoceptor blockers, although the acute migraine onset should be pharmacologically treated.
该研究的目的是比较成年偏头痛不一致的同胞手足在童年时期的性格和心理社会环境。这项研究涉及30对同胞手足,并使用了各种性格测试工具(艾森克人格问卷[EPI]、颜色词测试[CWT]、视觉后像[VAE]、元对比技术[MCT]、塞萨雷克-马克人格量表),结果显示偏头痛患者在神经质[EPI]方面得分显著更高,神经质也被称为情绪应激或特质焦虑;更敏感(MCT);并表现出更大的焦虑迹象(VAE、CWT)。此外,与无偏头痛的同胞手足相比,偏头痛患者在童年时期往往报告朋友更少,从父母那里得到的言语和非言语鼓励也更少。研究发现神经质与偏头痛显著相关,但与偏头痛组的头痛频率或严重程度无关。有人认为,由于一些偏头痛患者神经质水平较高,心理治疗应被视为替代其他预防性治疗(如使用β-肾上腺素能受体阻滞剂)的一种选择,不过偏头痛急性发作时应进行药物治疗。