Pfeifer M, Pollaehne W, Minne H W
Bad Pyrmonter Institute of Clinical Osteology Gustav Pommer, Germany.
Horm Metab Res. 1997 Feb;29(2):76-9. doi: 10.1055/s-2007-978990.
Broadband ultrasound attenuation (BUA) and speed of sound (SOS) were determined together with bone mineral density (BMD) of the lumbar spine and of the proximal right hip (QDR 2000, Hologic) in 1252 females (mean age 56 +/- 11). We then calculated the predictive power of BUA and SOS for at least one vertebral fracture and correlation-coefficients of BMD of the spine and hip as well as BUA and SOS in different age groups (SPSS PC + Vers. 2.2. for IBM PC software). The overall prevalence of at least one vertebral fracture was 10.14% (127 out of 1252 patients). The relative risk for the presence of at least one vertebral fracture was 2.7 for BMD spine below 0.7 g Calcium/cm2 (69 out of 249 patients), 1.8 for BMD hip below 0.7 g Calcium/cm2 (106 out of 589 patients), 1.9 for SOS calcaneus below 1500 m/s (99 out of 499 patients) and 1.7 for BUA calcaneus below 110 dB/MHz (103 out of 605 patients). The relative risk for the presence of at least one vertebral fracture increases significantly (p < 0.01). In the age group < 50 the coefficients of correlation were 0.4655 between BMD spine and BUA calcaneus, 0.5259 between BMD spine and SOS calcaneus, 0.4327 between BMD hip and BUA, 0.2760 between BMD hip and SOS. In the age group > 70 the coefficients of correlation were 0.3699 between BMD spine and BUA, 0.3481 between BMD spine and SOS, 0.5946 between BMD hip and BUA, 0.5138 between BMD hip and SOS, respectively. All coefficients of correlation were highly statistically significant (p < 0.001). We conclude that BUA and SOS predict relative risk of the presence of at least one vertebral fracture as well as BMD spine and BMD hip. With increasing age BUA and SOS appear to be an independent predictor, not being inevitably correlated to BMD but possibly reflecting different qualities of bone at different sites of the skeleton.
对1252名女性(平均年龄56±11岁)测定了跟骨宽带超声衰减(BUA)、声速(SOS)以及腰椎和右髋近端的骨密度(BMD,采用QDR 2000型Hologic骨密度仪)。然后我们计算了BUA和SOS对至少一处椎体骨折的预测能力,以及不同年龄组中脊柱和髋部BMD、BUA和SOS的相关系数(使用SPSS PC + Vers. 2.2. for IBM PC软件)。至少一处椎体骨折的总体患病率为10.14%(1252例患者中有127例)。脊柱BMD低于0.7 g钙/cm²时(249例患者中有69例),至少一处椎体骨折的相对风险为2.7;髋部BMD低于0.7 g钙/cm²时(589例患者中有106例),相对风险为1.8;跟骨SOS低于1500 m/s时(499例患者中有99例),相对风险为1.9;跟骨BUA低于110 dB/MHz时(605例患者中有103例),相对风险为1.7。至少一处椎体骨折的相对风险显著增加(p < 0.01)。在年龄<50岁的组中,脊柱BMD与跟骨BUA的相关系数为0.4655,脊柱BMD与跟骨SOS的相关系数为0.5259,髋部BMD与BUA的相关系数为0.4327,髋部BMD与SOS的相关系数为0.2760。在年龄>70岁的组中,脊柱BMD与BUA的相关系数为0.3699,脊柱BMD与SOS的相关系数为0.3481,髋部BMD与BUA的相关系数为0.5946,髋部BMD与SOS的相关系数为0.5138。所有相关系数均具有高度统计学显著性(p < 0.001)。我们得出结论,BUA和SOS与脊柱BMD和髋部BMD一样,可预测至少一处椎体骨折的相对风险。随着年龄增长,BUA和SOS似乎是独立的预测指标,它们与BMD并非必然相关,但可能反映了骨骼不同部位的不同骨质。