Muizelaar J P, Kleyer M, Hertogs I A, DeLange D C
Department of Neurosurgery, University of California, Davis, Sacramento 95817, USA.
Clin Neurol Neurosurg. 1997 Feb;99(1):26-30. doi: 10.1016/s0303-8467(96)00594-x.
Complex Regional Pain Syndrome (CRPS) is the new name for entities formerly known mostly as Reflex Sympathetic Dystrophy and Causalgia. Treatment of CRPS with either the calcium channel blocker nifedipine or the alpha-sympathetic blocker phenoxybenzamine was assessed in 59 patients, 12 with early stages of CRPS, 47 with chronic stage CRPS. In the early stage CRPS patients, 3 of 5 were cured with nifedipine and 8 of 9 (2 of whom had earlier received nifedipine) with phenoxybenzamine, for a cure rate of 92% (11 out of 12). In the chronic stage CRPS patients, 10 of 30 were cured with nifedipine; phenoxybenzamine cured 7 of 17 patients when administered as a first choice and another 2 of 7 patients who received nifedipine earlier, for a total late stage success rate of 40% (19 out of 47). The most common side effects necessitating discontinuing the drug were headaches for nifedipine and orthostatic dizziness, nausea and diarrhoea for phenoxybenzamine. All male patients on phenoxybenzamine experienced impotence, but this did not lead to discontinuing this agent and immediately disappeared after stopping the drug. These results once again stress the importance of early recognition of CRPS, and treatment with either of these drugs could be considered as a first choice for early CRPS, especially because in this series this treatment was not combined with physical therapy making it very cost-effective. In the chronic stage of CRPS, treatment with these drugs was much less successful (40%), even though it was always combined with physical therapy, but it can still be considered, either as a first choice or when other types of treatment have failed.
复杂性区域疼痛综合征(CRPS)是以前大多被称为反射性交感神经营养不良和灼性神经痛的病症的新名称。对59例患者评估了用钙通道阻滞剂硝苯地平或α-交感神经阻滞剂酚苄明治疗CRPS的效果,其中12例为CRPS早期患者,47例为CRPS慢性期患者。在CRPS早期患者中,5例中有3例用硝苯地平治愈,9例中有8例(其中2例先前接受过硝苯地平治疗)用酚苄明治愈,治愈率为92%(12例中的11例)。在CRPS慢性期患者中,30例中有10例用硝苯地平治愈;酚苄明作为首选药物时治愈了17例患者中的7例,另外7例先前接受过硝苯地平治疗的患者中有2例被治愈,晚期总成功率为40%(47例中的19例)。导致停药的最常见副作用,硝苯地平是头痛,酚苄明是体位性头晕、恶心和腹泻。所有服用酚苄明的男性患者均出现阳痿,但这并未导致停药,且停药后立即消失。这些结果再次强调了早期识别CRPS的重要性,对于早期CRPS,这两种药物中的任何一种都可被视为首选治疗药物,特别是因为在本系列研究中,这种治疗未与物理治疗相结合,因而成本效益很高。在CRPS慢性期,尽管总是与物理治疗相结合,但用这些药物治疗的成功率要低得多(40%),但仍可被视为首选或在其他类型治疗失败时使用。