Pryse-Phillips W E, Dodick D W, Edmeads J G, Gawel M J, Nelson R F, Purdy R A, Robinson G, Stirling D, Worthington I
Memorial University of Newfoundland.
CMAJ. 1997 May 1;156(9):1273-87.
To provide physicians and allied health care professionals with guidelines for the diagnosis and management of migraine in clinical practice.
The full range and quality of diagnostic and therapeutic methods available for the management of migraine.
Improvement in the diagnosis and treatment of migraine, which will lead to a reduction in suffering, increased productivity and decreased economic burden. EVIDENCE AND VALUES: The creation of the guidelines followed a needs assessment by members of the Canadian Headache Society and included a statement of objectives; development of guidelines by multidisciplinary working groups using information from literature reviews and other resources; comparison of alternative clinical pathways and description of how published data were analysed; definition of the level of evidence for data in each case; evaluation and revision of the guidelines at a consensus conference held in Ottawa on Oct. 27-29, 1995; redrafting and insertion of tables showing key variables and data from various studies and tables of data with recommendations; and reassessment by all conference participants.
BENEFITS, HARMS AND COSTS: Accuracy in diagnosis is a major factor in improving therapeutic effectiveness. Improvement in the precise diagnosis of migraine, coupled with a rational plan for the treatment of acute attacks and for prophylactic therapy, is likely to lead to substantial benefits in both human and economic terms.
The diagnosis of migraine can be improved by using modified criteria of the International Headache Society as well as a semistructured patient interview technique. Appropriate treatment of symptoms should take into account the severity of the migraine attack, since most patients will have attacks of differing severity and can learn to use medication appropriate for each attack. When headaches are frequent or particularly severe, prophylactic therapy should be considered. Both the avoidance of migraine trigger factors and the application of nonpharmacological therapies play important roles in overall migraine management and will be addressed at a later date.
The guidelines are based on consensus of Canadian experts in neurology, emergency medicine, psychiatry, psychology, family medicine and pharmacology, and consumers. Previous guidelines did not exist. Field testing of the guidelines is in progress.
为医生及相关医疗保健专业人员提供偏头痛临床诊断与管理指南。
偏头痛管理中可用的诊断和治疗方法的全面性及质量。
偏头痛诊断与治疗得到改善,这将减轻痛苦、提高生产力并减轻经济负担。证据与价值:本指南的制定遵循了加拿大头痛协会成员进行的需求评估,包括目标陈述;多学科工作组利用文献综述和其他资源中的信息制定指南;比较替代临床路径并描述如何分析已发表的数据;界定每个案例中数据的证据水平;在1995年10月27 - 29日于渥太华举行的共识会议上对指南进行评估和修订;重新起草并插入显示关键变量和来自各种研究的数据的表格以及带有建议的数据表格;并由所有会议参与者重新评估。
益处、危害与成本:诊断准确性是提高治疗效果的主要因素。偏头痛精确诊断的改善,再加上合理的急性发作治疗计划和预防性治疗计划,可能在人力和经济方面带来巨大益处。
使用国际头痛协会的修订标准以及半结构化患者访谈技术可改善偏头痛的诊断。症状的适当治疗应考虑偏头痛发作的严重程度,因为大多数患者会有不同严重程度的发作,并且可以学会使用适合每次发作的药物。当头痛频繁或特别严重时,应考虑预防性治疗。避免偏头痛触发因素和应用非药物疗法在偏头痛整体管理中都起着重要作用,这将在稍后进行探讨。
本指南基于加拿大神经病学、急诊医学、精神病学、心理学、家庭医学和药理学领域的专家以及消费者的共识制定。以前不存在相关指南。本指南的实地测试正在进行中。