Kotzerke J, Glatz S, Grillenberger K, Kleinschmidt K, Reske S N
Nuklearmedizin (Radiologie III), Universität Ulm, Germany.
Nucl Med Commun. 1997 Apr;18(4):352-7. doi: 10.1097/00006231-199704000-00175.
The aim of this study was to assess the intra-individual reproducibility of 99Tcm-mercaptoacetyltriglycine (99Tcm-MAG3) clearance in routine clinical practice in various circumstances using a single-sample method. Three groups of 30 patients each were enrolled in the study. Investigations were repeated on the same day with two different levels of activity (group A), within 1 week (group B), or after 1 year (group C). Blood samples were taken after 20 and 25 min and clearance values were averaged to minimize incidental errors after calculation according to the formula proposed by Bubeck et al. For clearance estimation on the same day, time-dependent background correction for residual activity was carried out. The mean difference was -2.0%, +6.0% and -1.5% (S.D. = 6.3%, 15.7% and 11.7%) for groups A, B and C respectively, taking into account values > 100 ml min-1 only. We demonstrated that 99Tcm-MAG3 clearance is highly reproducible under the same conditions. However, a repeat clearance measurement on a separate day revealed large differences. Therefore, in follow-up studies for evaluation of changing kidney function (e.g. surgery or chemotherapy), differences should exceed 30% (i.e. 2 S.D. of group B) to be statistically significant.
本研究的目的是使用单样本方法评估在各种情况下常规临床实践中99锝-巯基乙酰三甘氨酸(99Tcm-MAG3)清除率的个体内重复性。每组30例患者,共三组纳入本研究。在同一天以两种不同的活性水平(A组)、在1周内(B组)或1年后(C组)重复进行检查。在20分钟和25分钟后采集血样,并根据Bubeck等人提出的公式计算清除率值,然后求平均值以尽量减少偶然误差。对于同一天的清除率估计,对残留活性进行时间依赖性背景校正。仅考虑大于100 ml/min的值时,A组、B组和C组的平均差异分别为-2.0%、+6.0%和-1.5%(标准差分别为6.3%、15.7%和11.7%)。我们证明,在相同条件下99Tcm-MAG3清除率具有高度可重复性。然而,在另一天重复进行清除率测量时发现差异很大。因此,在评估肾功能变化的随访研究(如手术或化疗)中,差异应超过30%(即B组标准差的2倍)才有统计学意义。