Castellanos Ortega A, Ortiz Melón F, García Fuentes M, Prieto Valderrey F, Santidrián Miguel J P, Mazorra Macho F
UCI Pediátrica, Departamento de medicina intensiva, Valdecilla, Santander.
An Esp Pediatr. 1997 Mar;46(3):224-8.
Because of concerns about the declining autopsy rate, an attempt was made to evaluate the contributions from the postmortem examination in children.
We carried out a retrospective comparison analysis between clinical and pathological diagnosis of 56 consecutive autopsies performed on children who died in the PICU during the period 1983-1995.
The autopsy rate was 60%. Autopsy provided valuable clinical information in 50% of the cases. There were major diagnostic errors in three patients (5%), that if detected before death would probably have improved survival. Another 14 cases (25%) showed missed clinical diagnoses related to the basic illness and the cause of death, whose premortem diagnosis would not have prolonged survival. There were no diagnostic discrepancies in 28 cases (50%). The most unexpected findings revealed by the autopsies were iatrogenics (10 cases), metabolic diseases (4 cases), congenital immunodeficiency syndromes (4 cases) and pulmonary opportunistic infections (3 cases). Eight of these diseases were genetic. An age < 12 months or and ICU stay < 24 hours were not predicting factors of a higher incidence of major diagnostic errors.
The value of the autopsy as quality assurance and to detect iatrogenics and occult genetic diseases is unquestionable. New strategies have to be designed to increase the rate of autopsies.
鉴于对尸检率下降的担忧,尝试评估儿童尸检的贡献。
我们对1983年至1995年期间在儿科重症监护病房(PICU)死亡的儿童连续进行的56例尸检的临床诊断与病理诊断进行了回顾性对比分析。
尸检率为60%。尸检在50%的病例中提供了有价值的临床信息。有3例患者(5%)存在重大诊断错误,若在生前发现可能会改善生存情况。另外14例(25%)显示存在与基础疾病和死因相关的临床漏诊,其生前诊断并不会延长生存期。28例(50%)不存在诊断差异。尸检发现的最意外结果为医源性因素(10例)、代谢性疾病(4例)、先天性免疫缺陷综合征(4例)和肺部机会性感染(3例)。其中8种疾病为遗传性疾病。年龄<12个月或在重症监护病房停留时间<24小时并非重大诊断错误发生率较高的预测因素。
尸检作为质量保证以及检测医源性因素和隐匿性遗传疾病的价值是毋庸置疑的。必须设计新的策略来提高尸检率。