Davey P G, South R, Malek M
Pharmacoeconomics Research Centre, Ninewells Hospital and Medical School, Dundee, UK.
J Antimicrob Chemother. 1996 Mar;37(3):623-33. doi: 10.1093/jac/37.3.623.
Data were collected prospectively from 59 patients receiving vancomycin and 20 patients receiving teicoplanin. The mean daily drug cost was 52.40 pounds for teicoplanin and 31.13 pounds for vancomycin; the 95% Confidence Intervals (CI) for the difference in mean drug costs varied between 14.40 pounds and 28.10 pounds in favour of vancomycin. Use of a loading dose of teicoplanin significantly increased mean daily drug costs if the duration of treatment was less than 10 days. Costs of preparation, administration and monitoring were consistently higher for vancomycin than for teicoplanin and inclusion of these costs reduced the difference in mean daily costs to 13.01 pounds (95% CI 6.10 to 19.90 pounds). In Dundee 11 of 20 patients who received teicoplanin had received some of their treatment after discharge from the hospital and a survey of UK hospitals confirmed that teicoplanin treatment after discharge is being used in a wide range of conditions. The median proportion of teicoplanin treatment in Dundee given after discharge was 28.4% for each patient who received the drug: the median proportion of non-inpatient therapy was 50% per patient of those who received any teicoplanin treatment after discharge. Assuming that teicoplanin costs 20 pounds per day more than vancomycin, use of teicoplanin implies an investment of 70.42 pounds to gain one hospital day through earlier discharge of patients receiving teicoplanin.
前瞻性收集了59例接受万古霉素治疗的患者和20例接受替考拉宁治疗的患者的数据。替考拉宁的日均药物费用为52.40英镑,万古霉素为31.13英镑;平均药物费用差异的95%置信区间(CI)在14.40英镑至28.10英镑之间,有利于万古霉素。如果治疗持续时间少于10天,使用替考拉宁的负荷剂量会显著增加日均药物费用。万古霉素的配制、给药和监测成本始终高于替考拉宁,将这些成本纳入计算后,日均成本差异降至13.01英镑(95%CI 6.10至19.90英镑)。在邓迪,20例接受替考拉宁治疗的患者中有11例在出院后接受了部分治疗,对英国医院的一项调查证实,出院后使用替考拉宁治疗的情况广泛存在。在邓迪,接受替考拉宁治疗的患者出院后接受治疗的中位比例为每位患者28.4%:出院后接受任何替考拉宁治疗的患者中,非住院治疗的中位比例为每位患者50%。假设替考拉宁每天的费用比万古霉素高20英镑,使用替考拉宁可通过使接受替考拉宁治疗的患者更早出院,意味着投资70.42英镑来多获得一天住院时间。