Nachman J, Sather H N, Gaynon P S, Lukens J N, Wolff L, Trigg M E
University of Chicago, IL, USA.
J Clin Oncol. 1997 Jun;15(6):2222-30. doi: 10.1200/JCO.1997.15.6.2222.
Compared with previous Children's Cancer Group (CCG) acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL) trials, therapy based on the Berlin-Frankfurt-Munster (BFM) 76 trial has effected an improvement in event-free survival (EFS). In an attempt to improve EFS further, CCG investigators formulated an augmented BFM (A-BFM) regimen that provides prolonged, intensified postinduction chemotherapy relative to the CCG-modified BFM regimen.
We tested A-BFM in 101 patients with ALL and unfavorable presenting features that showed slow early response (SER) to induction therapy who attained remission on day 28. Their outcome was compared with that of 251 concurrent patients with unfavorable presenting features, a rapid early response to therapy (RER), and remission by day 28, treated with CCG-BFM with or without cranial radiation (CRT).
The 4-year EFS rate from the end of induction for SER patients treated with A-BFM was 70.8% +/- 4.6%. Seventeen patients remain in continuous remission beyond 5 years. Vincristine (VCR) neurotoxicity developed in 50% of patients, but was rarely debilitating. Allergies to Escherichia coli L-asparaginase (L-ASP) occurred in 35% of patients. Avascular necrosis of bone (AVN) developed in 9% of patients. In comparison, a concurrent RER group treated with standard BFM +/- CRT had a 4-year EFS rate of 73.1% +/- 4.6%.
The toxicity of A-BFM is significant, but acceptable. Compared with historical control SER patients treated with CCG-modified BFM, A-BFM therapy appears to produce a significant improvement in EFS. This is the first study to show that intensive chemotherapy, as given in the A-BFM regimen, can abrogate the adverse prognostic significance of SER.
与既往儿童癌症研究组(CCG)的急性淋巴细胞白血病(ALL)试验相比,基于柏林 - 法兰克福 - 明斯特(BFM)76试验的治疗方案使无事件生存期(EFS)得到了改善。为进一步提高EFS,CCG研究人员制定了强化BFM(A - BFM)方案,该方案相对于CCG改良BFM方案提供了更长时间、更强的诱导后化疗。
我们对101例ALL且具有不良表现特征、诱导治疗早期反应缓慢(SER)且在第28天达到缓解的患者进行了A - BFM方案测试。将他们的结果与251例同时期具有不良表现特征、治疗早期反应迅速(RER)且在第28天达到缓解、接受CCG - BFM方案(有或无颅脑放疗[CRT])治疗的患者的结果进行比较。
接受A - BFM治疗的SER患者从诱导结束起的4年EFS率为70.8%±4.6%。17例患者持续缓解超过5年。50%的患者发生长春新碱(VCR)神经毒性,但很少导致功能丧失。35%的患者对大肠杆菌L - 天冬酰胺酶(L - ASP)过敏。9%的患者发生骨缺血性坏死(AVN)。相比之下,接受标准BFM±CRT治疗的同期RER组4年EFS率为73.1%±4.6%。
A - BFM方案的毒性显著,但可以接受。与接受CCG改良BFM治疗的历史对照SER患者相比,A - BFM治疗似乎使EFS有显著改善。这是第一项表明A - BFM方案中所采用的强化化疗能够消除SER不良预后意义的研究。