Harger B L, Taylor J A, Haas M, Nyiendo J
Department of Radiology, Western States Chiropractic College, Portland, Oregon 97230, USA.
J Manipulative Physiol Ther. 1997 Jun;20(5):311-4.
To assess the chiropractic use of radiography, referral patterns to both medical and chiropractic radiologists and attitudes toward radiologists.
Random sample mail survey.
Practicing U.S. chiropractors.
The response rate was 46% (197 of 425). Seventy-four percent of the respondents have radiographic facilities in their offices. Contraindication screen (71%), pathological diagnosis (63%), biomechanics and posture (51%) and medicolegal protection (27%) were considered important reasons for taking radiographs. When chiropractors refer for radiographic services, 67% refer to medical radiologists and 17% to chiropractic radiologists. Eighty-five percent agreed that chiropractic radiologists are as well qualified as medical radiologists, but 36% thought that medical interpretation carried more legal authority than chiropractic interpretation. Seventy-six percent of respondents thought that the chiropractic radiologist should be consulted only for second opinions.
Most chiropractors obtain radiographs for clinical reasons, such as confirming a diagnosis of pathology, but many continue to use radiography as a screening tool and for medicolegal protection. Prevailing attitudes seem to indicate a need for this specialty in chiropractic, but the chiropractic radiological consultant is not widely used. The disparity between the perceived need for chiropractic radiologists and the current utilization patterns requires further research.
评估脊椎按摩疗法从业者使用X光摄影的情况、转介给医学放射科医生和脊椎按摩疗法放射科医生的模式以及对放射科医生的态度。
随机抽样邮件调查。
美国执业脊椎按摩疗法从业者。
回复率为46%(425人中197人回复)。74%的受访者在其办公室设有X光摄影设备。禁忌筛查(71%)、病理诊断(63%)、生物力学和姿势(51%)以及法医学保护(27%)被认为是进行X光摄影的重要原因。当脊椎按摩疗法从业者转介进行X光摄影服务时,67%转介给医学放射科医生,17%转介给脊椎按摩疗法放射科医生。85%的人认为脊椎按摩疗法放射科医生与医学放射科医生资质相当,但36%的人认为医学解读比脊椎按摩疗法解读具有更高的法律效力。76%的受访者认为仅应在寻求第二种意见时咨询脊椎按摩疗法放射科医生。
大多数脊椎按摩疗法从业者出于临床原因进行X光摄影,如确诊病理,但许多人仍将X光摄影用作筛查工具和法医学保护手段。普遍态度似乎表明脊椎按摩疗法领域需要这一专业,但脊椎按摩疗法放射学顾问的使用并不广泛。脊椎按摩疗法放射科医生的感知需求与当前使用模式之间的差异需要进一步研究。