Schwartz L B, Belkin M, Donaldson M C, Knox J B, Craig D M, Moawad J, McKinsey J F, Piano G, Bassiouny H S, Whittemore A D
Department of Surgery, University of Chicago, Ill, USA.
J Vasc Surg. 1997 Jun;25(6):1033-41; discussion 1041-3. doi: 10.1016/s0741-5214(97)70127-7.
Clinical studies have revealed that the most important predictor of successful bypass grafting is the origin and quality of the bypass conduit. Attempts at intraoperative evaluation of the hemodynamic properties of the conduit, including assessment of blood flow (Q), pressure gradients (delta P), and resistance (R), have not been useful. This is because each of these parameters measures the characteristics of the graft plus the outflow bed. To date, no specific measurement of the resistive properties of the conduit only is available. The purpose of this investigation was to evaluate longitudinal impedance (ZL) as a measure of conduit-specific resistance and to evaluate its potential in predicting the outcome of infrainguinal vascular reconstructions.
ZL was measured during surgery in 73 infrainguinal autologous vein reconstructions performed in 68 patients in two separate institutions over a 21-month period. Vein graft ultrasonic transit time Q and delta P (from proximal to distal anastomosis) were measured at baseline and after maximal peripheral vasodilatation with an intraarterial injection of papaverine 30 mg. Waveforms were recorded for 10 seconds at 200 Hz using a digital acquisition system. R was calculated as proximal mean pressure divided by mean blood flow (Q). After Fourier transformation, ZL was calculated as delta P/Q at each harmonic and total ZL (integral of ZL) was defined as the integral of moduli from 0 to 4 Hz.
All hemodynamic variables were significantly affected by papaverine vasodilatation (delta P, 3.9 +/- 0.5 vs 6.3 +/- 0.8 mm Hg; Q, 78.2 +/- 7.0 vs 126 +/- 11 ml/min; R, 134 +/- 17 vs 72.7 +/- 6.2 x 10(3) dyne.sec.cm-5; p < 0.0001), except integral of ZL, which remained constant (31.1 +/- 2.8 vs 30.8 +/- 2.8 x 10(3) dyne.cm-5; p = NS). After follow-up of 1 week to 17 months (median, 5 months), the 1-year primary, primary-assisted, and secondary patency rates were 72% +/- 7%, 77% +/- 6%, and 81% +/- 6%, respectively. Using Cox analysis, primary patency was significantly associated with decreased integral of ZL (p = 0.0001), but not with baseline or papaverine-stimulated delta P, Q, delta P/Q, or R integral of ZL > 47 x 10(3) dyne.cm-5 predicted primary failure with 90% positive and negative predictive value.
Intraoperative measurement of integral of ZL in infrainguinal vein grafts is independent of outflow conditions (that is, does not change with papaverine), and hence describes the resistive properties of the conduit only. In addition, these preliminary data suggest that integral of ZL is predictive of short-term primary patency. integral of ZL is the first available hemodynamic measurement that is conduit-specific and may therefore be a better predictor of graft patency than currently available methods.
临床研究表明,旁路移植成功的最重要预测因素是旁路管道的起源和质量。对管道血流动力学特性进行术中评估的尝试,包括评估血流量(Q)、压力梯度(ΔP)和阻力(R),均未取得成效。这是因为这些参数中的每一个都测量了移植物加上流出床的特性。迄今为止,尚无仅针对管道电阻特性的具体测量方法。本研究的目的是评估纵向阻抗(ZL)作为一种衡量管道特定阻力的指标,并评估其在预测股腘动脉血管重建结果方面的潜力。
在21个月的时间里,于两个不同机构对68例患者进行的73例股腘动脉自体静脉重建手术中测量了ZL。在基线时以及经动脉内注射30mg罂粟碱使外周血管最大程度扩张后,测量静脉移植物的超声传输时间Q和ΔP(从近端吻合口到远端吻合口)。使用数字采集系统以200Hz记录10秒的波形。R计算为近端平均压力除以平均血流量(Q)。经过傅里叶变换后,在每个谐波处将ZL计算为ΔP/Q,总ZL(ZL积分)定义为从0至4Hz的模量积分。
除ZL积分保持恒定外(31.1±2.8对30.8±2.8×10³达因·厘米⁻⁵;p =无显著性差异),所有血流动力学变量均受到罂粟碱血管扩张的显著影响(ΔP,3.9±0.5对6.3±0.8mmHg;Q,78.2±7.0对126±11ml/min;R,134±17对72.7±6.2×10³达因·秒·厘米⁻⁵;p < 0.0001)。在随访1周到17个月(中位数为5个月)后,1年的一期通畅率、一期辅助通畅率和二期通畅率分别为72%±7%、77%±6%和81%±6%。使用Cox分析,一期通畅与ZL积分降低显著相关(p = 0.0001),但与基线或罂粟碱刺激后的ΔP、Q、ΔP/Q或R无关。ZL积分>47×10³达因·厘米⁻⁵预测一期失败的阳性和阴性预测值均为90%。
股腘静脉移植物术中ZL积分的测量不受流出条件的影响(即不会因罂粟碱而改变),因此仅描述了管道的阻力特性。此外,这些初步数据表明ZL积分可预测短期一期通畅情况。ZL积分是首个可用的针对特定管道的血流动力学测量指标,因此可能比现有方法更能准确预测移植物通畅情况。