Wigren T, Oksanen H, Kellokumpu-Lehtinen P
Department of Oncology and Radiotherapy, Medical School, University of Tampere, Finland.
J Cancer Res Clin Oncol. 1997;123(5):259-66. doi: 10.1007/BF01208636.
Radical radiotherapy is widely used to treat inoperable non-small-cell lung cancer (NSCLC) although only a small number of patients benefit in the long run from this intensive treatment. There is a small proportion of long-term survivors who might derive advantage from even more aggressive radiotherapy combined with chemotherapy. In order to support optimal treatment selection we have carried out univariate and multivariate analyses of possible prognostic variables in the retrospective data of 502 NSCLC patients treated at one institute with external radiotherapy, both with curative and palliative intent. To obtain more accurate tools for a rational treatment decision, we identified, by using Cox's proportional-hazards model, the five most powerful determinants of overall survival and combined them to a prognostic index. On the basis of only the number of these risk factors (advanced stage, general or metastatic symptoms, poor performance status, anemia and tumor size of at least 7 cm), the patient falls into one of the six possible prognostic groups and these groups turned out to be identifiable as separate prognostic clusters. Thirty-one per cent of the patients have three or more risk factors and a median survival of 5-7 months compared with 18 months for patients without any non-favorable factor. Furthermore, the prognostic factors were so strong that multivariate analyses did not reveal the treatment selection to have any significant influence on survival. As each of the five variables have the advantage of being routinely available, our index is simple enough to be used in daily clinical practice. The clinical value of the prognostic index should be verified by using independent data.
根治性放疗广泛应用于无法手术的非小细胞肺癌(NSCLC)的治疗,尽管从长远来看只有少数患者能从这种强化治疗中获益。有一小部分长期存活者可能会从更积极的放疗联合化疗中获益。为了支持最佳治疗方案的选择,我们对一家机构采用外照射放疗(包括根治性和姑息性目的)治疗的502例NSCLC患者的回顾性数据进行了单因素和多因素分析,以探讨可能的预后变量。为了获得更准确的工具来做出合理的治疗决策,我们使用Cox比例风险模型确定了总生存的五个最有力的决定因素,并将它们组合成一个预后指数。仅根据这些危险因素(晚期、全身或转移症状、体能状态差、贫血以及肿瘤大小至少7cm)的数量,患者可分为六个可能的预后组,结果表明这些组可被识别为不同的预后集群。31%的患者有三个或更多危险因素,中位生存期为5至7个月,而无任何不利因素的患者中位生存期为18个月。此外,预后因素非常显著,多因素分析未显示治疗选择对生存有任何显著影响。由于这五个变量中的每一个都具有常规可得的优势,我们的指数足够简单,可用于日常临床实践。预后指数的临床价值应通过使用独立数据进行验证。