Kaim A, Maurer T, Ochsner P, Jundt G, Kirsch E, Mueller-Brand J
Institute of Nuclear Medicine, University Hospital Basel, Switzerland.
Eur J Nucl Med. 1997 Jul;24(7):732-8. doi: 10.1007/BF00879660.
Chronic post-traumatic osteomyelitis (OM) represents a particular challenge for nuclear medicine and radiology since clinical and biochemical parameters are frequently unreliable. The aim of this study was to investigate the value of combined bone scan (BS) and immunoscintigraphy (IS) with technetium-99m labelled monoclonal antigranulocyte antibody (MAB) in patients with suspected chronic OM of the appendicular skeleton. Twenty-four patients (17 females and 7 males) with suspected chronic post-traumatic OM were evaluated with three-phase BS/99mTc-MAB-IS. The final diagnosis was established by means of bone culture and histology in 19 cases and clinical follow-up in five cases. The studies were reviewed by two independent and experienced observers; the interobserver agreement was calculated by kappa statistics. The sensitivity, specificity and accuracy of BS alone were 92%, 18% and 58%, respectively. Combined BS/99mTc-MAB-IS had a sensitivity, specificity and accuracy of 84%, 72% and 79%, respectively. Of 24 studies, 11 were true-positive, two false-negative, eight true-negative and three false-positive. Two patients presented with unexpected ectopic haematopoietic bone marrow in the appendicular skeleton that caused false-positive results. A high degree of interobserver agreement was found (kappa=0. 85). It is concluded that combined BS/99mTc-MAB-IS represents a very sensitive and reproducible method with an acceptable specificity for the investigation of chronic OM. Problems may occur in the differentiation of low-grade OM from aseptic inflammation. Another problem is ectopic marrow that may occur in the appendicular skeleton due to a chronic inflammatory stimulus. A former intramedullary intervention in the femur with displacement of haematopoietic marrow may also lead to an ectopic location.
慢性创伤后骨髓炎(OM)对核医学和放射学来说是一项特殊挑战,因为临床和生化参数常常不可靠。本研究的目的是探讨联合骨扫描(BS)和免疫闪烁显像(IS)以及用锝-99m标记的单克隆抗粒细胞抗体(MAB)在怀疑患有附肢骨骼慢性OM患者中的价值。对24例(17例女性和7例男性)怀疑患有慢性创伤后OM的患者进行了三相BS/99mTc-MAB-IS评估。最终诊断通过骨培养和组织学在19例中确定,在5例中通过临床随访确定。研究由两名独立且经验丰富的观察者进行审查;观察者间的一致性通过kappa统计计算。单独BS的敏感性、特异性和准确性分别为92%、18%和58%。联合BS/99mTc-MAB-IS的敏感性、特异性和准确性分别为84%、72%和79%。在24项研究中,11项为真阳性,2项为假阴性,8项为真阴性,3项为假阳性。2例患者在附肢骨骼中出现意外的异位造血骨髓,导致假阳性结果。发现观察者间一致性程度较高(kappa=0.85)。结论是,联合BS/99mTc-MAB-IS是一种非常敏感且可重复 的方法,对慢性OM的检查具有可接受的特异性。在区分低度OM与无菌性炎症时可能会出现问题。另一个问题是由于慢性炎症刺激,附肢骨骼中可能出现异位骨髓。先前在股骨进行的骨髓腔内干预导致造血骨髓移位也可能导致异位位置。