Merget R, Dierkes A, Rückmann A, Bergmann E M, Schultze-Werninghaus G
Abteilung für Pneumologie, Allergologie und Schlafmedizin, Universitäts-klinik, Bochum.
Pneumologie. 1997 Apr;51(4):345-50.
There is evidence that bronchial responsiveness to allergen is quantitatively correlated with bronchial responsiveness to nonspecific stimuli in subjects with allergic asthma. This association has been questioned in occupational asthma due to low molecular weight substances. It was the aim of this study to assess the quantitative association of bronchial responsiveness to methacholine (MCH) and platinum salts (Pt), in the form of hexachloroplatinic acid, in workers with occupational asthma due to Pt salts. Fifty-seven subjects with exposure to Pt, work-related asthma, and a positive bronchial challenge with Pt underwent skin prick test with Pt and bronchial challenge with MCH. Using the provocation concentration causing a > or = 50% fall in specific airway conductance (PC50sGaw(Pt)) as a dependent variable, anamnestic data (period from first symptoms to removal, period between removal from exposure and diagnosis, and smoking), season of the investigation, skin prick tests with environmental allergens, total immunoglobulin E (IgE), skin reactivity to Pt (Pt concentration causing a 2 mm wheal), and PC50sGaw(MCH) were included as independent variables for regression analysis. Fifty-two subjects (91%) showed a PC50sGaw(MCH) < 8 mg.mL-1 (geometric mean for all subjects 1.6 mg.mL-1). Responsiveness to Pt varied widely between subjects (geometric mean of PC50sGaw(Pt) 9 x 10(-5) mol.L-1, range 2 x 10(-7) to 10(-2) mol.L-1). There was no univariate correlation between bronchial responsiveness to MCH and Pt, but there was a correlation between skin reactivity to Pt and PC50sGaw(Pt) (r = 0.6). This association could not be improved by considering PC50sGaw(MCH), the period from first symptoms to removal, or the period between removal from exposure and diagnosis. The parameters that showed the highest (negative) associations with PC50sGaw(Pt) were skin reactivity to Pt and the period between removal from exposure and diagnosis (r = 0.65). We conclude that there is a moderate association between bronchial responsiveness to platinum salts and skin reactivity to platinum salts. However, there is no association between methacholine responsiveness and bronchial responsiveness to allergen in occupational asthma due to platinum salts.
有证据表明,在过敏性哮喘患者中,支气管对过敏原的反应性与支气管对非特异性刺激的反应性存在定量相关性。在由低分子量物质引起的职业性哮喘中,这种关联受到了质疑。本研究的目的是评估六氯铂酸形式的支气管对乙酰甲胆碱(MCH)和铂盐(Pt)的反应性在因铂盐导致职业性哮喘的工人中的定量关联。57名接触Pt、患有职业性哮喘且对Pt支气管激发试验呈阳性的受试者接受了Pt皮肤点刺试验和MCH支气管激发试验。以导致特异性气道传导率下降≥50%的激发浓度(PC50sGaw(Pt))作为因变量,将既往病史数据(从首次出现症状到脱离接触的时间、脱离接触到诊断的时间以及吸烟情况)、调查季节、环境过敏原皮肤点刺试验、总免疫球蛋白E(IgE)、对Pt的皮肤反应性(引起2mm风团的Pt浓度)以及PC50sGaw(MCH)作为回归分析的自变量。52名受试者(91%)的PC50sGaw(MCH)<8mg·mL-1(所有受试者的几何平均值为1.6mg·mL-1)。受试者对Pt的反应性差异很大(PC50sGaw(Pt)的几何平均值为9×10-5mol·L-1,范围为2×10-7至10-2mol·L-1)。支气管对MCH和Pt的反应性之间无单变量相关性,但对Pt的皮肤反应性与PC50sGaw(Pt)之间存在相关性(r = 0.6)。考虑PC50sGaw(MCH)、从首次出现症状到脱离接触的时间或脱离接触到诊断的时间,这种关联并未得到改善。与PC50sGaw(Pt)显示出最高(负)相关性的参数是对Pt的皮肤反应性以及脱离接触到诊断的时间(r = 0.65)。我们得出结论,支气管对铂盐的反应性与对铂盐的皮肤反应性之间存在中度关联。然而,在因铂盐导致的职业性哮喘中,乙酰甲胆碱反应性与支气管对过敏原的反应性之间不存在关联。