Stronks K, van de Mheen H, van den Bos J, Mackenbach J P
Department of Public Health, Erasmus University, Rotterdam, The Netherlands.
Int J Epidemiol. 1997 Jun;26(3):592-600. doi: 10.1093/ije/26.3.592.
The aim of the study was to test the hypothesis that the relatively strong association between income and health compared to that between education/occupation and health, can partly be interpreted in terms of an association between employment status and health.
Health indicators used were the prevalence of one or more chronic conditions, and perceived general health. Data were generated from a postal survey, part of the baseline data collection of a Dutch prospective cohort study on socioeconomic inequalities in health.
After controlling for differences in other socioeconomic indicators, the association between income and health was found to be stronger than that between occupation or education and health. Most of the difference in strength was found to be due to employment status, especially among men. Controlling for employment status, and controlling for the distribution of those with a long-term work disability in particular, reduced the risks of lower income groups, whereas the risks of lower educational and occupational groups hardly changed.
These results suggest that the relatively strong association between income and health can for a large part be interpreted in terms of an interrelationship between employment status, income and health. More specifically, it is largely due to the concentration of the long-term disabled in lower income groups. This indicates the importance of the selection mechanism, as these groups are excluded from paid employment because of their health status, leading to a lowering of income. However, income was still found to be related to perceived general health after controlling for employment status especially among women. This suggests that an explanation in terms of an effect of material factors on health may also be important.
本研究的目的是检验一个假设,即与教育/职业和健康之间的关联相比,收入与健康之间相对较强的关联,部分可以从就业状况与健康之间的关联角度来解释。
所使用的健康指标为一种或多种慢性病的患病率以及自我感知的总体健康状况。数据来自一项邮寄调查,该调查是荷兰一项关于健康方面社会经济不平等的前瞻性队列研究基线数据收集的一部分。
在控制了其他社会经济指标的差异后,发现收入与健康之间的关联比职业或教育与健康之间的关联更强。发现强度差异的大部分原因是就业状况,尤其是在男性中。控制就业状况,特别是控制长期工作残疾者的分布,降低了低收入群体的风险,而低教育程度和低职业群体的风险几乎没有变化。
这些结果表明,收入与健康之间相对较强的关联在很大程度上可以从就业状况、收入和健康之间的相互关系角度来解释。更具体地说,这主要是由于长期残疾者集中在低收入群体中。这表明了选择机制的重要性,因为这些群体由于健康状况而被排除在有偿就业之外,导致收入降低。然而,在控制就业状况后,仍发现收入与自我感知的总体健康状况有关,尤其是在女性中。这表明物质因素对健康的影响这一解释可能也很重要。