Assalia A, Kopelman D, Bahous H, Klein Y, Hashmonai M
Dept. of Surgery B, Rambam Medical Center, Haifa.
Harefuah. 1997 May 1;132(9):629-33.
The therapeutic effect of gastrografin is occasionally mentioned in the literature. However, this effect has not been objectively evaluated. We studied prospectively the effect of Gastrografin in cases of adhesive, simple, partial, small bowel obstruction (SBO) compared to conventional management. During 3 years, a total of 137 episodes of simple, partial SBO in 127 patients (10 recurrent episodes) were treated. The episodes were randomized into a control group (80 episodes), treated conventionally, and a trial group (77 episodes), which received in addition 100 ml of Gastrografin administered through the nasogastric tube. The two groups were well-matched with regard to age, gender, weight, medical and surgical background and duration of complaints before admission. Time to first stool and resolution of obstruction, complications, need for surgery, and hospital stay were noted. Mean time to first stool was significantly shorter in the trial group: 6.2 +/- 3.9 hours vs 23.5 +/- 12.7 (p < .0001). Mean hospital stay for unoperated patients was also shorter in the trial group: 2.7 +/- 2 days vs 5.5 +/- 2 days, (p < .0001). In addition, significantly fewer episodes in the trial group required operation, 10.4 vs 26.7% (p < 0.013). 1 patient in each group dies following operation. There were no Gastrografin-related complications and it was effective and safe for adhesive, partial, simple SBO. It significantly speeds resolution of obstruction, reduces the need for operation, and shortens convalescence.
文献中偶尔会提到泛影葡胺的治疗效果。然而,这种效果尚未得到客观评估。我们前瞻性地研究了泛影葡胺与传统治疗方法相比,在粘连性、单纯性、部分性小肠梗阻(SBO)病例中的疗效。在3年期间,共治疗了127例患者的137次单纯性、部分性SBO发作(10次复发发作)。这些发作被随机分为对照组(80次发作),采用传统方法治疗,以及试验组(77次发作),试验组除传统治疗外,还通过鼻胃管给予100 ml泛影葡胺。两组在年龄、性别、体重、医疗和手术背景以及入院前症状持续时间方面匹配良好。记录首次排便时间、梗阻解除时间、并发症、手术需求和住院时间。试验组首次排便的平均时间明显更短:6.2±3.9小时 vs 23.5±12.7小时(p<0.0001)。试验组未手术患者的平均住院时间也更短:2.7±2天 vs 5.5±2天(p<0.0001)。此外,试验组需要手术的发作次数明显更少,分别为10.4%和26.7%(p<0.013)。每组各有1例患者术后死亡。未出现与泛影葡胺相关的并发症,它对粘连性、部分性、单纯性SBO有效且安全。它能显著加快梗阻的解除,减少手术需求,并缩短康复时间。