Wiebke E A, Grieshop N A, Sidner R A, Howard T J, Yang S
Department of Surgery, Indiana University Medical Center, Indianapolis, USA.
J Surg Res. 1997 Jun;70(1):89-94. doi: 10.1006/jsre.1997.5082.
L-Arginine has been described as a potential immunostimulant in vitro and in vivo. Excessive arginine, however, may be counterproductive. Data support the concept of minimal arginine requirements for normal lymphocyte proliferation, but the results of supplementation with pharmacologic doses of arginine have been contradictory. We hypothesized that excessive arginine supplementation might result in a blunting of normal immune responses of human lymphocytes in vitro.
Peripheral blood mononuclear and T-cells were isolated from normal human donors. Cells were cultured in complete media with various concentrations of L-arginine, L-ornithine, and glycine. Lymphocytes were then stimulated with PHA or alloantigens, and proliferation was determined by measuring [3H]thymidine incorporation.
Lymphocyte proliferation was inhibited by L-arginine at pharmacologic doses. The effects were completely reversible. This inhibition could not be prevented by lymphocyte stimulation with IL-2. Lymphocyte proliferation was more sensitive to inhibition by lower doses of arginine when alloantigens from irradiated fresh tumor cells or allogeneic lymphocytes were the stimuli. Finally, lymphocytes showed variable sensitivity to inhibition of proliferation in response to mitogen when treated with L-ornithine (little to no effect) or L-arginine (consistent inhibition at high doses). Pharmacologic doses of L-arginine result in reversible inhibition of normal lymphocyte proliferation in response to both mitogen and alloantigen. This inhibition could not be blocked by interleukin-2.
We conclude that caution should be exercised when recommending aggressive L-arginine supplementation as a possible method to reverse clinical immunosuppression caused by cancer, malnutrition, or trauma.
L-精氨酸在体外和体内均被描述为一种潜在的免疫刺激剂。然而,过量的精氨酸可能会适得其反。数据支持正常淋巴细胞增殖所需精氨酸量极少这一概念,但补充药理剂量精氨酸的结果却相互矛盾。我们推测,在体外,过量补充精氨酸可能会导致人类淋巴细胞正常免疫反应减弱。
从正常人类供体中分离出外周血单个核细胞和T细胞。将细胞在含有不同浓度L-精氨酸、L-鸟氨酸和甘氨酸的完全培养基中培养。然后用PHA或同种异体抗原刺激淋巴细胞,并通过测量[3H]胸腺嘧啶核苷掺入量来测定增殖情况。
药理剂量的L-精氨酸可抑制淋巴细胞增殖。这种作用是完全可逆的。用IL-2刺激淋巴细胞并不能阻止这种抑制作用。当以照射过的新鲜肿瘤细胞或同种异体淋巴细胞的同种异体抗原作为刺激物时,较低剂量的精氨酸对淋巴细胞增殖的抑制作用更敏感。最后,当用L-鸟氨酸(几乎无作用)或L-精氨酸(高剂量时持续抑制)处理时,淋巴细胞对有丝分裂原刺激的增殖抑制表现出不同的敏感性。药理剂量的L-精氨酸可导致正常淋巴细胞对有丝分裂原和同种异体抗原的增殖反应受到可逆性抑制。这种抑制作用不能被白细胞介素-2阻断。
结论我们得出结论,在推荐积极补充L-精氨酸作为逆转由癌症、营养不良或创伤引起的临床免疫抑制的可能方法时应谨慎。