Hermann K L, Egund N
Department of Radiology, National University Hospital, Copenhagen, Denmark.
Acta Radiol. 1997 Jul;38(4 Pt 1):527-32. doi: 10.1080/02841859709174381.
To evaluate CT methods of measuring anteversion in the femoral neck with respect to measurement accuracy and with respect to the influence exerted by different femoral shaft positions; and to describe a new CT measurement concept that introduces a mathematical adjustment for different femoral shaft positions. The new technique facilitates the taking of measurements in patients who cannot be correctly positioned in traditional methods.
CT examinations of previously measured anteversions in the femoral neck were reviewed in retrospect in 30 patients with fractures of the femoral neck. The position of the femoral shaft was assessed. A reference angle was compared with direct traditional measurements and with measurements adjusted for the actual position of the femoral shaft by means of a 3D mathematical reconstruction. Reproducibility and inter- and intraobserver variability were assessed in 10 cases.
All femurs varied in position within the gantry. The mean difference between the direct CT measurement and the adjusted CT measurement compared to the reference angle were -8.8 degrees (range -35.0-16.3 degrees) and -0.1 degrees (range -1.4-1.4 degrees), respectively. For the adjusted CT method, reproducibility and inter- and intraobserver variability were 1.4 degrees, 1.6 degrees and 1.4 degrees (SD of difference), respectively.
CT measurement of femoral anteversion in clinical practice can only be accurate when corrected for variation in the position of the femoral shaft.
评估测量股骨颈前倾角的CT方法在测量准确性方面以及不同股骨干位置所产生的影响;并描述一种新的CT测量概念,该概念针对不同股骨干位置引入了数学调整。这项新技术便于对无法通过传统方法正确定位的患者进行测量。
回顾性分析30例股骨颈骨折患者之前测量股骨颈前倾角的CT检查结果。评估股骨干的位置。将一个参考角度与直接的传统测量值以及通过三维数学重建根据股骨干实际位置调整后的测量值进行比较。对10例患者评估了测量的可重复性以及观察者间和观察者内的变异性。
所有股骨在扫描架内的位置均有差异。与参考角度相比,直接CT测量值与调整后的CT测量值之间的平均差值分别为-8.8度(范围为-35.0至16.3度)和-0.1度(范围为-1.4至1.4度)。对于调整后的CT方法,可重复性以及观察者间和观察者内的变异性分别为1.4度、1.6度和1.4度(差值的标准差)。
在临床实践中,只有对股骨干位置的变化进行校正后,CT测量股骨前倾角才能准确。