Navío P, Jiménez D, Pérez-Rodríguez E, Gaudó J, Lastra E, Valiño J
Servicio de Neumología, Hospital Ramón y Cajal, Madrid, España.
Respiration. 1997;64(4):296-9. doi: 10.1159/000196690.
In 97 cases of pulmonary tuberculosis (PTB), we analyzed the incidence of atypical roentgenographic locations, roentgenographic patterns, the correlation between the diagnostic yield and the roentgenographic pattern and the usefulness of simple or induced sputum (82 cases), bronchoaspirate (BAS; 29 cases), postfiberoptic bronchoscopy sputum (PFBS; 16 cases) and how the different tests supplemented each other. Atypical locations were defined as those not corresponding to classic primary and postprimary PTB. This atypical-location PTB index was 8.2%, and roentgenographic patterns found most frequently were: destructive 52.5%, destructive-alveolar 20.6% and alveolar 12.3%. Lowenstein-Jensen (LJ) culture of the sputum of alveolar-pattern cases improved acid-fast bacillus (AFB) diagnosis by 46% (p < 0.005), in contrast to other radiologic patterns. Simple or induced sputum proved to be a very good diagnostic specimen in 98% of the cases (AFB staining 73.1% and LJ culture 89%). BAS increased the sputum yield by 21% and PFBS contributed only 1 additional case to the results obtained with BAS. Therefore, BAS is a very good supplemental test in cases of false-negative findings.
在97例肺结核(PTB)患者中,我们分析了非典型X线表现部位的发生率、X线表现类型、诊断阳性率与X线表现类型之间的相关性,以及单纯痰液或诱导痰液(82例)、支气管吸出物(BAS;29例)、纤维支气管镜检查后痰液(PFBS;16例)的诊断价值,以及不同检测方法之间如何相互补充。非典型部位定义为不符合经典原发性和继发性PTB的部位。这种非典型部位PTB的发生率为8.2%,最常见的X线表现类型为:破坏性52.5%、破坏性-肺泡型20.6%和肺泡型12.3%。与其他放射学表现类型相比,肺泡型病例痰液的罗-琴(LJ)培养使抗酸杆菌(AFB)诊断率提高了46%(p < 0.005)。在98%的病例中,单纯痰液或诱导痰液被证明是非常好的诊断标本(AFB染色阳性率为73.1%,LJ培养阳性率为89%)。BAS使痰液获取量增加了21%,而PFBS仅在BAS检测结果的基础上额外增加了1例阳性病例。因此,在出现假阴性结果的病例中,BAS是一种非常好的补充检测方法。