Wright R E, Ellis P K
Department of Radiology, Ulster Hospital, Dundonald, Belfast, Northern Ireland, UK.
Dis Esophagus. 1997 Jul;10(3):211-4; discussion 215-6. doi: 10.1093/dote/10.3.211.
We assessed the accuracy of patient localization of the site of dysphagia and its implications for radiological practice during the barium swallow examination. Several current texts dispute the value of such information. Fifty-two consecutive patients with dysphagia were asked to localize the site of discomfort on the skin surface. The ability of each patient to do so precisely or vaguely was noted. A detailed barium examination of the pharynx, esophagus and stomach was performed. Results suggested that patients who had symptoms more cranial than the sternal notch were highly accurate at localizing disease. Localization became less precise as symptoms moved caudally towards the epigastrium. Lateralization of symptoms was highly accurate in determining the site of pathology. In conclusion, we feel that in certain circumstances the barium examination can be usefully tailored to accelerate examination times, thus reducing radiation exposure and cost whilst improving diagnostic accuracy.
我们评估了患者对吞咽困难部位的定位准确性及其在吞钡检查期间对放射学实践的影响。目前有几篇文献对这类信息的价值提出了质疑。我们连续邀请了52名吞咽困难患者在皮肤表面定位不适部位。记录了每位患者精确或模糊定位的能力。对咽部、食管和胃部进行了详细的钡剂检查。结果表明,症状位于胸骨切迹上方的患者在定位疾病方面高度准确。随着症状向尾侧移向剑突下,定位的精确性降低。症状的侧别在确定病变部位方面高度准确。总之,我们认为在某些情况下,吞钡检查可以进行有效调整以加快检查时间,从而减少辐射暴露和成本,同时提高诊断准确性。