Manning W J
Department of Medicine, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center and Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts 02215, USA.
Am J Cardiol. 1997 Aug 28;80(4C):19D-28D; discussion 35D-39D. doi: 10.1016/s0002-9149(97)00581-x.
Cardiac causes of stroke account for approximately 20% of strokes occurring in the United States. Transthoracic echocardiography (TTE) remains the cornerstone of non-invasive cardiac imaging, but transesophageal echocardiography (TEE) is superior for identifying potential cardiac sources of emboli, including left atrial thrombi, valvular vegetations, thoracic aortic plaque, patent foramen ovale, and spontaneous left atrial echocardiographic contrast. The diagnostic yield of TEE for potential cardiac causes of thromboembolism exceeds 50%. The impact of TEE on the clinical management of this group, however, remains undefined for most TEE-specific diagnoses. Thus, routine use of TEE in these patients has been questioned. The diagnostic yield is highest if the clinical history/physical examination suggests a cardiac source. However, the clinical scenario often dictates patient management, and TEE data are used to "validate" the clinical impression. Data from large, prospective, randomized (aspirin/warfarin) studies, in which TEE data are obtained from patients with suspected cardiac thromboembolism, are needed. If specific TEE diagnoses can be identified in which defined therapies are beneficial, "source of embolism" will continue to be the most common indication for TEE referral. In this paradigm, TEE (without initial TTE) will probably become a more direct diagnostic pathway. However, if these studies demonstrate that all patients with suspected cardiac source benefit from one (or no) therapy, independent of TEE data, referrals for TEE will decline. Results of ongoing randomized trials to evaluate the efficacy of TEE in patients with cryptogenic stroke or transient ischemic attack are awaited.
在美国,心脏源性卒中约占所有卒中病例的20%。经胸超声心动图(TTE)仍然是非侵入性心脏成像的基石,但经食管超声心动图(TEE)在识别潜在的心脏栓子来源方面更具优势,包括左心房血栓、瓣膜赘生物、胸主动脉斑块、卵圆孔未闭以及自发性左心房超声造影。TEE对潜在心脏源性血栓栓塞的诊断率超过50%。然而,对于大多数TEE特异性诊断而言,TEE对该组患者临床管理的影响仍不明确。因此,在这些患者中常规使用TEE受到了质疑。如果临床病史/体格检查提示心脏来源,诊断率最高。然而,临床情况往往决定患者的管理方式,TEE数据用于“验证”临床印象。需要来自大型、前瞻性、随机(阿司匹林/华法林)研究的数据,这些研究中TEE数据来自疑似心脏血栓栓塞的患者。如果能够确定特定的TEE诊断,且明确的治疗方法有益,“栓塞来源”将继续是TEE转诊最常见的指征。在这种模式下,TEE(不进行初始TTE)可能会成为更直接的诊断途径。然而,如果这些研究表明,所有疑似心脏来源的患者,无论TEE数据如何,都能从一种(或不进行)治疗中获益,那么TEE转诊将会减少。正在进行的评估TEE对不明原因卒中或短暂性脑缺血发作患者疗效的随机试验结果值得期待。