Noack K
Z Erkr Atmungsorgane. 1979 Apr;153(1):132-8.
Comparing studies has been demonstrated wether or not the cold staining of acid fast bacilli is qualitative and quantitative better than the Ziehl-Neelsen-method. The hot staining was superior to all cold staining methods and their modifications tested. If a cold staining is necessary two methods are recommended, the Kinyoun method and the staining with carbolfuchsin which chloroform is added to. Thin smear and homogeneous material provide better results. Additional investigations concerning decolorizations have shown, that 10% sulfuric acid is as effective as hydrochloric acid-ethanol mixture.
比较研究已经证明,抗酸杆菌的冷染色在定性和定量方面是否比齐尔-尼尔森方法更好。热染色优于所有测试的冷染色方法及其改进方法。如果需要冷染色,推荐两种方法,金扬法和添加了氯仿的石炭酸复红染色法。薄涂片和均匀材料能提供更好的结果。关于脱色的进一步研究表明,10%硫酸与盐酸-乙醇混合物的效果一样。