Billings J A, Block S
Palliative Care Service, Massachusetts General Hospital and Harvard Medical School, Boston 02114-2698, USA.
JAMA. 1997 Sep 3;278(9):733-8.
To describe the status of palliative care education in the undergraduate medical curriculum and to offer recommendations for improvement.
Review of literature on palliative care and of recently submitted grants on medical education for end-of-life care.
English-language reports of educational programs targeted toward medical students were examined, as well as surveys of medical schools.
Studies were reviewed by the authors to assess the quality of the educational program, evaluation methodology, and conclusions. From over 9000 citations on palliative care and related topics that were retrieved from MEDLINE searches from 1980 through 1995, and from reviewing 14 palliative care journals published from 1985 through 1996, 310 articles were identified that addressed medical education for end-of-life care, and 180 were carefully examined.
While nearly all medical schools offer some formal teaching about end-of-life care, there is considerable evidence that current training is inadequate, most strikingly in the clinical years. Teaching about palliative care is received favorably by students, positively influences student attitudes, and enhances communication skills. However, curricular offerings are not well integrated; the major teaching format is the lecture; formal teaching is predominantly preclinical; clinical experiences are mostly elective; there is little attention to home care, hospice, and nursing home care; role models are few; and students are not encouraged to examine their personal reactions to these clinical experiences.
The increasing attention to palliative care education has created major opportunities for improving education about care at the end of life. Educational programs should be rigorously evaluated to identify best educational practices.
描述本科医学课程中姑息治疗教育的现状,并提出改进建议。
查阅有关姑息治疗的文献以及最近提交的关于临终关怀医学教育的资助申请。
审查针对医学生的教育项目的英文报告以及医学院校的调查。
作者对研究进行了审查,以评估教育项目的质量、评估方法和结论。从1980年至1995年通过医学文献数据库检索到的9000多条关于姑息治疗及相关主题的文献引用,以及对1985年至1996年出版的14种姑息治疗期刊的审查中,共识别出310篇涉及临终关怀医学教育的文章,并对其中180篇进行了仔细研究。
虽然几乎所有医学院校都提供一些关于临终关怀的正式教学,但有大量证据表明目前的培训不足,在临床阶段最为明显。学生对姑息治疗教学评价良好,对学生态度有积极影响,并能提高沟通技巧。然而,课程设置整合不佳;主要教学形式是讲座;正式教学主要在临床前进行;临床经验大多是选修的;对家庭护理、临终关怀和养老院护理关注较少;榜样很少;而且不鼓励学生审视自己对这些临床经验的个人反应。
对姑息治疗教育的日益关注为改善临终关怀教育创造了重大机遇。应严格评估教育项目,以确定最佳教育实践。