Worthington H, Holloway P, Clarkson J, Davies R
Dental Health Unit, Turner Dental School, Manchester, UK.
Community Dent Oral Epidemiol. 1997 Aug;25(4):273-7. doi: 10.1111/j.1600-0528.1997.tb00939.x.
This prospective study was conducted to determine factors important in predicting which regularly attending adult patients would receive first, restorations or extractions for any reason (receiving treatment) and, second, restorations or extractions undertaken specifically for caries (receiving treatment related to caries). Baseline and incremental clinical data were obtained from 24 general dental practitioners on a group of their regularly attending, dentate adult patients over a 12-month period. The patients completed a postal questionnaire with questions relating to dental health behaviour, attitudes, knowledge, and social factors. Complete data were obtained from 2553 patients. Thirty-one variables were identified as potential predictors for the two dependent variables receiving treatment and receiving treatment related to caries, and logistic regression models were fitted. Receiving treatment was associated with having fewer sound teeth and more anterior fillings, posterior fillings and crowns (P < 0.001). The dentist's prediction of the need for treatment related to caries and the patient's own prediction of the need for a filling were also important in the model (P < 0.001). Some of these variables, together with having received recent medical treatment and taking sugar in tea or coffee were also found to predict treatment related to caries. The model for receiving treatment related to caries was more successful at predicting the patient's individual risk but the model for receiving treatment was slightly better at classifying patients into whether or not they received treatment. It is reassuring that the common assumptions made by the dental practitioners of their patient's risk have received statistical validation.
本前瞻性研究旨在确定预测哪些成年常客患者会因任何原因接受首次修复或拔牙(接受治疗),以及哪些患者会因龋齿专门接受修复或拔牙(接受与龋齿相关的治疗)的重要因素。在12个月的时间里,从24名普通牙科医生那里获取了一组定期就诊的有牙的成年患者的基线和增量临床数据。患者填写了一份邮寄问卷,其中包含与牙齿健康行为、态度、知识和社会因素相关的问题。从2553名患者那里获得了完整数据。确定了31个变量作为接受治疗和接受与龋齿相关治疗这两个因变量的潜在预测因素,并拟合了逻辑回归模型。接受治疗与健康牙齿较少、前牙充填物较多、后牙充填物较多以及牙冠较多有关(P < 0.001)。在该模型中,牙医对与龋齿相关治疗需求的预测以及患者自身对补牙需求的预测也很重要(P < 0.001)。还发现其中一些变量,连同近期接受过医疗治疗以及在茶或咖啡中加糖,也能预测与龋齿相关的治疗。与龋齿相关治疗的模型在预测患者个体风险方面更成功,但接受治疗的模型在将患者分类为是否接受治疗方面略胜一筹。令人欣慰的是,牙科医生对其患者风险的常见假设得到了统计验证。