Baddoura R, Awada H, Okais J, Habis T, Attoui S, Abi Saab M
Rheumatology Department, Hôtel-Dieu de France Hospital, Beirut, Lebanon.
Rev Rhum Engl Ed. 1997 Jul-Sep;64(7-9):459-64.
Cases of definite and probable spondylarthropathy were diagnosed based on the clinical judgement of participating rheumatologists, without reference to the two criteria sets under study. The first two patients without spondylarthropathy seen after each spondylarthropathy case were included into the control group. Criteria in the ESSG and B. Amor sets were looked for in the patient and control groups. The frequency of spondylarthropathy meeting each criteria set was determined.
Of the 841 patients evaluated during the study period, 68 met B. Amor's criteria and 72 met ESSG criteria. There were 29 cases of ankylosing spondylitis (40.3%), ten of peripheral psoriatic arthritis (13.8%), two of reactive arthritis (2.8%), two of enteropathic arthropathy (2.8%), and 29 of undifferentiated spondylarthropathy (40.3%). In the definite spondylarthropathy group, sensitivity and specificity were 77.19% and 97.55% for B. Amor's criteria versus 91.23% and 100% for ESSG criteria. The frequency of spondylarthropathy was 8.1% (95% confidence interval [CI], 6.3-9.9) or 8.56% (CI 6.6-10.5) according to B. Amor and ESSG criteria, respectively.
Our data validate both criteria sets in the Lebanese population, demonstrating that they are useful in populations that are genetically different from the European populations used to develop them. Spondyloarthropathy is the most common in our rheumatology practice.
1)验证欧洲脊柱关节病研究组(ESSG)和B. 阿莫尔(B. Amor)的脊柱关节病诊断标准在黎巴嫩的适用性。2)评估黎巴嫩风湿病临床实践中脊柱关节病的发病率。
根据参与研究的风湿病学家的临床判断诊断确诊和疑似脊柱关节病病例,不参考正在研究的这两套标准。每例脊柱关节病病例之后所见的前两名无脊柱关节病患者被纳入对照组。在患者组和对照组中查找ESSG和B. 阿莫尔标准中的各项指标。确定符合每套标准的脊柱关节病发病率。
在研究期间评估的841例患者中,68例符合B. 阿莫尔标准,72例符合ESSG标准。其中有29例强直性脊柱炎(40.3%),10例外周型银屑病关节炎(13.8%),2例反应性关节炎(2.8%),2例肠病性关节炎(2.8%),29例未分化脊柱关节病(40.3%)。在确诊的脊柱关节病组中,B. 阿莫尔标准的敏感性和特异性分别为77.19%和97.55%,而ESSG标准的敏感性和特异性分别为91.23%和100%。根据B. 阿莫尔标准和ESSG标准,脊柱关节病的发病率分别为8.1%(95%置信区间[CI],6.3 - 9.9)和8.56%(CI 6.6 - 10.5)。
我们的数据验证了这两套标准在黎巴嫩人群中的适用性,表明它们对于与制定这些标准时所依据的欧洲人群基因不同的人群是有用的。脊柱关节病在我们的风湿病临床实践中最为常见。