Dann E J, Daugherty C K, Larson R A
Department of Medicine, The University of Chicago, IL 60637-1470, USA.
Bone Marrow Transplant. 1997 Sep;20(5):369-74. doi: 10.1038/sj.bmt.1700904.
The relative benefit of allogeneic bone marrow transplantation (alloBMT) vs autologous BMT (autoBMT) for patients with relapsed or refractory Hodgkin's disease (HD) or non-Hodgkin's lymphoma (NHL) remains uncertain. Toxicity from graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) may diminish the potential benefits both of graft-versus-tumor activity and of receiving uncontaminated donor marrow stem cells. From 1987 to 1995, 27 adults (ages 18-60 years; median 36) underwent alloBMT for lymphoma after failure of standard chemotherapy. Twenty-one had NHL and six had HD (nodular sclerosis). Thirteen patients had primary refractory disease or chemotherapy-resistant relapses; two of these had relapsed after autoBMT. Three patients had untested relapses (one of them had relapsed after autoBMT), and 11 had chemotherapy-sensitive relapses. Twenty-four received HLA-matched bone marrow from a sibling (one twin); three received haploidentical marrow cells. Nine (33%) died from lymphoma. Eleven (41%) died of treatment-related causes. Opportunistic infections were a substantial problem leading to eight of these deaths (30%). Six patients (22%) survive free of lymphoma 17-70 months post-BMT (median, 56 months); four had had sensitive relapses, one had had a resistant relapse, and one had had nontested relapse. Three have chronic GVHD (limited in one; extensive in two). One HD patient who had relapsed after autoBMT remains in remission 19 months after alloBMT. No therapy-related myelodysplasia has been observed. We conclude that alloBMT has substantial morbidity in heavily pretreated lymphoma patients due to acute toxicity, infections and GVHD. However, 22% of our HD/NHL patients have had long-term disease-free survival.
对于复发或难治性霍奇金淋巴瘤(HD)或非霍奇金淋巴瘤(NHL)患者,异基因骨髓移植(alloBMT)与自体骨髓移植(autoBMT)相比的相对益处仍不确定。移植物抗宿主病(GVHD)的毒性可能会降低移植物抗肿瘤活性和接受未受污染的供体骨髓干细胞的潜在益处。1987年至1995年,27名成年人(年龄18 - 60岁;中位数36岁)在标准化疗失败后接受了淋巴瘤的alloBMT。21人患有NHL,6人患有HD(结节硬化型)。13名患者患有原发性难治性疾病或化疗耐药性复发;其中2人在autoBMT后复发。3名患者有未经检测的复发(其中1人在autoBMT后复发),11人有化疗敏感复发。24人接受了来自同胞(一对双胞胎)的HLA匹配骨髓;3人接受了单倍体相合骨髓细胞。9人(33%)死于淋巴瘤。11人(41%)死于治疗相关原因。机会性感染是导致其中8例死亡(30%)的一个重大问题。6名患者(22%)在BMT后17 - 70个月(中位数56个月)无淋巴瘤存活;4人有敏感复发,1人有耐药复发,1人有未经检测的复发。3人有慢性GVHD(1人局限型;2人广泛型)。1名在autoBMT后复发的HD患者在alloBMT后19个月仍处于缓解期。未观察到治疗相关的骨髓发育异常。我们得出结论,由于急性毒性、感染和GVHD,alloBMT在经过大量预处理的淋巴瘤患者中具有较高的发病率。然而,我们的HD/NHL患者中有22%实现了长期无病生存。