Zehr E P, Sale D G
Division of Neuroscience, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Canada.
Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1997 Oct;29(10):1383-8. doi: 10.1097/00005768-199710000-00017.
The reproducibility of ballistic actions performed on a custom-made apparatus was assessed in six untrained men who reported to the laboratory two times over a span of 10 d, on each occasion performing three isometric maximal voluntary contractions (MVC, elbow extension) and 10 ballistic elbow extension movements in each of two conditions: unloaded (L0) and with a load equal to 10% MVC (L10). For both the average of the trials and the best trial, method errors and Pearson correlation coefficients (r) were calculated for isometric peak torque and 10 (5 at each of L0 and L10) selected ballistic movement parameters (peak torque, peak rate of torque development, movement time, peak velocity, and peak acceleration). Based on method errors obtained and given an alpha level of 0.05 and power of 0.9, needed sample sizes were calculated for treatment effects ranging from 5 to 20%. Method errors for isometric peak torque were 5.1 and 3.1% for best and average of trials, respectively. For the 10 ballistic parameters, the corresponding method errors averaged 7.1 +/- 5.4% (SD) and 6.8 +/- 3.6%. The largest method errors were found in peak torque and peak rate of torque development with L0. The expected high negative correlation between method errors and r values was not found. For 5, 10, and 20% treatment effects, 4, 6, and 9 of 10 best trial measures met the sample size criterion of N < or = 20. For the average of trials, 3, 8, and all 10 met the criterion. With the exception of rate of torque development, the reproducibility of the described ballistic measures is acceptable for longitudinal training studies and cross-sectional group comparisons.
在一个定制设备上进行的弹道动作的可重复性,在六名未经训练的男性中进行了评估。这些男性在10天的时间里分两次到实验室报到,每次在两种条件下进行三次等长最大自主收缩(MVC,伸肘)和10次弹道式伸肘动作:无负荷(L0)和负荷等于10%MVC(L10)。对于试验的平均值和最佳试验,计算了等长峰值扭矩以及10个(L0和L10各5个)选定的弹道运动参数(峰值扭矩、扭矩发展峰值速率、运动时间、峰值速度和峰值加速度)的方法误差和皮尔逊相关系数(r)。根据获得的方法误差,并给定α水平为0.05和检验效能为0.9,计算了5%至20%治疗效果所需的样本量。等长峰值扭矩的方法误差,最佳试验和试验平均值分别为5.1%和3.1%。对于10个弹道参数,相应的方法误差平均为7.1±5.4%(标准差)和6.8±3.6%。在L0条件下,峰值扭矩和扭矩发展峰值速率的方法误差最大。未发现方法误差与r值之间预期的高度负相关。对于5%、10%和20%的治疗效果,10个最佳试验测量值中有4个、6个和9个满足样本量标准N≤20。对于试验平均值,3个、8个和全部10个满足标准。除扭矩发展速率外,所描述的弹道测量的可重复性对于纵向训练研究和横断面组比较是可以接受的。