Tranel D, Damasio H, Damasio A R
Department of Neurology, University of Iowa College of Medicine, Iowa City, USA.
Neuropsychologia. 1997 Oct;35(10):1319-27. doi: 10.1016/s0028-3932(97)00085-7.
Both clinical reports and systematic neuropsychological studies have shown that patients with damage to selected brain sites develop defects in the retrieval of conceptual knowledge for various concrete entities, leading to the hypothesis that the retrieval of knowledge for entities from different conceptual categories depends on partially segregated large-scale neural systems. To test this hypothesis, 116 subjects with focal, unilateral lesions to various sectors of the telencephalon, and 55 matched controls, were studied with a procedure which required the visual recognition of entities from three categories--unique persons, non-unique animals and non-unique tools. Defective recognition of persons was associated with maximal lesion overlap in right temporal polar region; defective recognition of animals was associated with maximal lesion overlap in right mesial occipital/ventral temporal region and also in left mesial occipital region; and defective recognition of tools was associated with maximal lesion overlap in the occipital-temporal-parietal junction of the left hemisphere. The findings support the hypothesis that the normal retrieval of knowledge for concrete entities from different conceptual domains depends on partially segregated neural systems. These sites may operate as catalysts for the retrieval of the multidimensional aspects of knowledge which are necessary and sufficient for the mental representation of a concept of a given entity.
临床报告和系统性神经心理学研究均表明,特定脑区受损的患者在提取各类具体实体的概念知识时会出现缺陷,这引发了一种假说,即从不同概念类别中提取实体知识依赖于部分分离的大规模神经系统。为验证这一假说,研究人员对116名大脑半球特定区域单侧受损的受试者以及55名匹配的对照组进行了研究,采用的程序要求对三类实体进行视觉识别,即特定人物、非特定动物和非特定工具。对人物的识别缺陷与右侧颞极区域的最大病变重叠相关;对动物的识别缺陷与右侧枕叶内侧/颞叶腹侧区域以及左侧枕叶内侧区域的最大病变重叠相关;对工具的识别缺陷与左侧半球枕颞顶交界处的最大病变重叠相关。这些发现支持了这样一种假说,即从不同概念领域正常提取具体实体知识依赖于部分分离的神经系统。这些脑区可能作为催化剂,促进对知识多维度方面的提取,而这些方面对于给定实体概念的心理表征是必要且充分的。