Wilson T, Hyde M
Centre for Deafness Studies and Research, Faculty of Education, Griffith University, Brisbane, Australia.
Am Ann Deaf. 1997 Oct;142(4):333-41. doi: 10.1353/aad.2012.0232.
Many deaf students have severe difficulty acquiring literacy and developing reading comprehension beyond an elementary school level. This difficulty apparently results from a combination of perceptual, communication, instructional, linguistic, and experiential deficits. Although some deaf students develop a degree of signed English proficiency, this does not necessarily translate into reading proficiency. Recent studies examining the possible association between signed English pictures and comprehension of printed text present some support for facilitation of students' word recognition in a format combining those two elements. Whether this format enhances comprehension remains unclear from previous studies. The present study, involving 16 severely or profoundly deaf students across two reading-proficiency groups, examined whether the use of signed English pictures in association with printed text enhances students' reading comprehension. The study found that comprehension was significantly enhanced by the use of signed English reading books, with poorer readers deriving greater benefit than better readers. Practical implications of the findings are discussed.
许多失聪学生在获取读写能力以及发展超出小学水平的阅读理解能力方面存在严重困难。这种困难显然是由感知、沟通、教学、语言和经验缺陷共同造成的。尽管一些失聪学生在一定程度上掌握了手语英语,但这并不一定能转化为阅读能力。最近的研究探讨了手语英语图片与印刷文本理解之间可能存在的关联,这些研究为以结合这两种元素的形式促进学生的单词识别提供了一些支持。从先前的研究来看,这种形式是否能提高阅读理解尚不清楚。本研究涉及两个阅读能力组的16名重度或极重度失聪学生,研究了使用手语英语图片与印刷文本相结合是否能提高学生的阅读理解能力。研究发现,使用手语英语阅读书籍能显著提高阅读理解能力,阅读能力较差的学生比阅读能力较好的学生受益更大。文中讨论了这些研究结果的实际意义。