Devlin G, Lazzam L, Schwartz L
Department of Medicine, Toronto Hospital, Ontario, Canada.
Int J Card Imaging. 1997 Oct;13(5):379-84; discussion 385-6. doi: 10.1023/a:1005822729543.
The mortality of diagnostic catheterization is very low but still exists. Large series have documented left main disease as the most important anatomical risk factor but have not clarified the mechanism.
To determine the mortality of diagnostic catheterization in a single high volume centre over a 9 year period and assess any change during this period; to compare this experience with that of larger multicentre surveys; to identify the clinical and anatomical risk factors; to investigate the mechanism of the event; to develop guidelines for prevention
Cardiac catheterization records were reviewed over a 9 year period and patients dying during or within 24 hours were identified. The clinical and anatomical profile of the patients who died were compared with the overall group to search for independent risk factors. The angiograms of the deaths were reviewed for a mechanism.
There were 30 deaths in 42,345 procedures (0.071%). There was no change in the incidence over the 9 years. Left main coronary disease was an overwhelming risk factor (incidence 0.7%, p < .002 compared to all other subgroups) and no other anatomical subgroup including triple vessel disease was at greater risk than the overall group. Dissection of the left main coronary artery by the diagnostic catheter was the mechanism of death in 20 cases (67%)
Left main disease and catheter induced trauma are the most important risk factor for and mechanism of death during diagnostic catheterization and may account for the unchanging incidence. Technical guidelines are described which may reduce this risk.
诊断性心导管检查的死亡率很低,但仍然存在。大量研究已将左主干病变记录为最重要的解剖学危险因素,但尚未阐明其机制。
确定在一个高工作量的单一中心9年期间诊断性心导管检查的死亡率,并评估在此期间的任何变化;将此经验与更大规模的多中心调查结果进行比较;确定临床和解剖学危险因素;研究该事件的机制;制定预防指南。
回顾9年期间的心脏导管检查记录,确定在检查期间或24小时内死亡的患者。将死亡患者的临床和解剖学特征与总体组进行比较,以寻找独立危险因素。复查死亡患者的血管造影片以寻找机制。
在42345例手术中有30例死亡(0.071%)。9年期间发病率没有变化。左主干冠状动脉疾病是一个压倒性的危险因素(发病率0.7%,与所有其他亚组相比,p<0.002),包括三支血管病变在内的其他解剖亚组的风险均不高于总体组。诊断性导管导致左主干冠状动脉夹层是20例(67%)死亡的机制。
左主干病变和导管引起的创伤是诊断性心导管检查期间死亡的最重要危险因素和机制,可能是发病率不变的原因。文中描述了可能降低这种风险的技术指南。