Stroke. 1997 Nov;28(11):2139-44. doi: 10.1161/01.str.28.11.2139.
We sought to clarify the way in which organized inpatient (stroke unit) care can produce reductions in case fatality and in the need for institutional care after stroke.
We performed a secondary analysis of a collaborative systematic review of all randomized trials that compared organized inpatient (stroke unit) care with contemporary conventional care. Nineteen trials were included, of which 18 (3246 patients) could provide outcome data on death, place of residence, and final functional outcome. Data were less complete (but always available for at least 12 trials; 1611 patients) for subgroup analyses examining timing and cause of death and outcomes in patients with different levels of severity of initial stroke.
The reduction in case fatality of patients managed in a stroke unit setting developed between 1 and 4 weeks after the index stroke. The reduction in the odds of death was evident across all causes of death and most marked for those deaths considered to be secondary to immobility. However, data were insufficient to permit a firm conclusion. The relative increase in the number of patients discharged home from stroke units as opposed to conventional care was largely attributable to an increase in the number of patients returning home physically independent. Across the range of stroke severity, stroke unit care was associated with nonsignificant increases in the number of patients regaining independence.
Within the limitations of the available data, we conclude that organized inpatient stroke unit care probably benefits a wide range of stroke patients in a variety of different ways, ie, reducing death from secondary complications of stroke and reducing the need for institutional care through a reduction in disability.
我们试图阐明有组织的住院(卒中单元)护理能够降低卒中病死率以及减少卒中后机构护理需求的方式。
我们对一项协作系统评价进行了二次分析,该评价纳入了所有比较有组织的住院(卒中单元)护理与当代常规护理的随机试验。共纳入19项试验,其中18项(3246例患者)能够提供关于死亡、居住地点及最终功能结局的结局数据。对于检查死亡时间、死亡原因以及初始卒中严重程度不同的患者的结局的亚组分析,数据完整性稍差(但至少12项试验;1611例患者)。
在卒中单元接受治疗的患者病死率的降低在索引卒中后1至4周出现。所有死因的死亡几率均有降低,对于那些被认为继发于活动不便的死亡最为明显。然而,数据不足以得出确切结论。与常规护理相比,卒中单元出院回家的患者数量相对增加主要归因于身体独立回家的患者数量增加。在整个卒中严重程度范围内,卒中单元护理与患者恢复独立的数量非显著性增加相关。
在现有数据的局限性内,我们得出结论,有组织的住院卒中单元护理可能以多种不同方式使广泛的卒中患者受益,即降低卒中继发并发症导致的死亡,并通过减少残疾来降低机构护理需求。