Bethune E, Jackling N
Deakin University School of Nursing, Melbourne, Australia.
J Adv Nurs. 1997 Nov;26(5):1005-12. doi: 10.1046/j.1365-2648.1997.00394.x.
The critical thinking skills students bring with them on entering university courses will necessarily have a bearing on how they manage their studies and gain new knowledge. This study examined postgraduate nursing students' perceptions of their gains in critical thinking abilities through engagement in off-campus studies after three semesters of study. Data for the study were collected by survey methodology. Descriptive statistics were derived and correlation analyses performed using SPSSx. This study indicates that for most skills, the differences between those students with prior university experience and those without it in perceptions of change in skill ability were not marked. For most critical thinking skills, about one half or a little more of the students perceived an overall positive shift in their abilities. For some skills, however, there were marked differences in the proportion of students perceiving a shift in skill ability, and possible explanations are offered. The results also indicate that a considerable proportion of the students surveyed perceived a lack of critical thinking skill development. As a result questions can be raised about how off-campus students without prior university experience engage with tertiary studies. The implications of these findings in terms of the development of off-campus nursing course materials and student learning are discussed.
学生进入大学课程时所具备的批判性思维技能必然会影响他们的学习管理方式和新知识获取。本研究调查了研究生护理专业学生在三个学期的校外学习后,对自身批判性思维能力提升的看法。研究数据通过调查方法收集。使用SPSSx进行描述性统计并进行相关性分析。本研究表明,对于大多数技能而言,有大学学习经历的学生与没有大学学习经历的学生在技能能力变化认知上的差异并不显著。对于大多数批判性思维技能,约一半或略多于一半的学生认为自己的能力有总体上的积极提升。然而,对于某些技能,在认为技能能力有提升的学生比例上存在显著差异,并给出了可能的解释。结果还表明,相当一部分接受调查的学生认为批判性思维技能发展不足。因此,可以提出关于没有大学学习经历的校外学生如何参与高等教育学习的问题。讨论了这些研究结果对校外护理课程材料开发和学生学习的影响。