Hanson R R, Zavala D C, Rhodes M L, Keim L W, Smith J D
Am Rev Respir Dis. 1976 Jul;114(1):67-72. doi: 10.1164/arrd.1976.114.1.67.
The diagnostic accuracy and complication rate of transbronchial forceps lung biopsy combined with bronchial brushing were analyzed in 164 consecutive patients, of whom 95 had nonmalignant disease and 51 had malignant disease. Eighteen patients with abnormal chest radiographs had normal transbronchial forceps lung biopsies and no established diagnosis. Satisfactory specimens were obtained in 153 patients (93 per cent), with diagnositc accuracies of 62, 64, and 67 per cent, respectively, in infectious, interstitial, and malignant lung disease. The over-all diagnostic accuracy was 57 per cent. Seven patients were diagnosed as having metastatic carcinoma to the lung by transbronchial forceps lung biopsy, but brush biopsy was psoitive in only 3. Of the 23 patients with primary lung carcinoma diagnosed by transbronchial forceps lung biopsy, 21 had positive brush biopsies. An additional 3 patients with bronchogenic carcinoma, however, were diagnosed only by brush biopsy. Fluoroscopy was essential for accurate positioning of the biopsy instrument. Increased risk factors were present in 83 patients (51 per cent), among whom the immunosuppressed group presented special problems. Significant bleeding in 15 patients (9 per cent) was controlled by conservative management. Pneumothorax occurred in 7 patients (4 per cent). There were no deaths. Transbronchial forceps lung biopsy in experienced hands is safe and well tolerated. The physician, nevertheless, must be prepared to handle major complications, especially bleeding. The procedure has a resonable diagnostic yield in high-risk patients who have a variety of lung lesions.
对164例连续患者分析了经支气管钳取肺活检联合支气管刷检的诊断准确性和并发症发生率,其中95例患有非恶性疾病,51例患有恶性疾病。18例胸部X线片异常的患者经支气管钳取肺活检结果正常,未确诊。153例患者(93%)获得了满意的标本,在感染性、间质性和恶性肺部疾病中的诊断准确率分别为62%、64%和67%。总体诊断准确率为57%。7例患者经支气管钳取肺活检诊断为肺转移癌,但刷检仅3例阳性。在经支气管钳取肺活检诊断为原发性肺癌的23例患者中,21例刷检阳性。然而,另有3例支气管源性癌患者仅通过刷检确诊。荧光镜检查对于活检器械的准确定位至关重要。83例患者(51%)存在增加的危险因素,其中免疫抑制组存在特殊问题。15例患者(9%)出现明显出血,经保守治疗得到控制。7例患者(4%)发生气胸。无死亡病例。在经验丰富的医生操作下,经支气管钳取肺活检是安全的,耐受性良好。然而,医生必须准备好处理主要并发症,尤其是出血。该方法在患有各种肺部病变的高危患者中具有合理的诊断率。