Gómez I, Coma L, Morillo F, Camí J
Centro de Información y Documentación-CSIC, Madrid.
Med Clin (Barc). 1997 Oct 18;109(13):497-505.
MEDICINA CLINICA has been indexed in the Science Citation Index (SCI) database since 1992, listed in the category Medicine, General & Internal, and its impact factor in 1993 was 0.909. Two years as source journal in the SCI database provide enough information to assess its contribution to the international scientific scenario.
Publications of Spanish authors in MEDICINA CLINICA during 1992 and 1993 were retrieved from the SCI. Document types, geographic distribution, institutional sectors, subjects and most productive centers were analyzed. All documents retrieved from the SCI were compared manually with those published in the journal itself. Citations received until November 1996 were collected and reference patterns assessed.
MEDICINA CLINICA was in the upper third of the list of journals of its category ranked by their impact factor. As other general medical journals, it was characterized by the publication of a high number of letters to the editor (48% of documents) and of articles susceptible of being classified in other disciplines according to their contents. Main topics of documents authored by Spanish authors included: Infectious Diseases (15%), Pharmacy/Pharmacology (8.8%), Cancer/Oncology (7.2%), Cardiovascular System (4.9%), Epidemiology/Public Health (4.5%), Endocrinology/Metabolism (4%) and Neurosciences/Neurology (4%). Only 32% of studies corresponding to citable items had been carried out in Barcelona, the city in which the journal is published, 19.5% in Madrid, and almost 9% in Andalucia. Around 66% of articles and only 25% of letters have received at least one citation, with a mean number of citations of 2.83 for articles and 1.3 for letters. Self-citations from other documents published in the same journal were high (77.8% for articles) as compared with citations received from other international SCI journals. Reference patterns found in MEDICINA CLINICA were similar to those of high-ranking journals of the same category. The comparison of documents published in MEDICINA CLINICA to those retrieved from SCI showed a lack of consistency in document types. In respect to the authors' last names, potential problems due to heterogeneity of the bibliographic names of Spanish authors are added to SCI-derived typing errors.
MEDICINA CLINICA appears open to a broad spectrum of authors, centers and topics. Highly productive health centers in MEDICINA CLINICA are also highly productive in other international journals. Differences between what is published in the journal and how this information is indexed in the SCI database constitute an important obstacle, not only for the journal's visibility, but also for a comprehensive retrieval of the authors' output. Changes in the classification of documents and consistent criteria in the use of bibliographic names of authors are recommended.
《临床医学》自1992年起被收录于科学引文索引(SCI)数据库,归类于医学、综合与内科领域,其1993年的影响因子为0.909。在SCI数据库中作为来源期刊的两年提供了足够信息来评估其对国际科学领域的贡献。
从SCI中检索1992年和1993年西班牙作者在《临床医学》上发表的文章。分析文献类型、地理分布、机构部门、主题以及产出最多的中心。将从SCI中检索到的所有文献与该期刊自身发表的文献进行人工比对。收集截至1996年11月收到的引用情况并评估参考文献模式。
《临床医学》在按影响因子排名的同类期刊列表中处于前三分之一。与其他综合医学期刊一样,其特点是发表大量给编辑的信(占文献的48%)以及根据内容可归类于其他学科的文章。西班牙作者撰写的文献主要主题包括:传染病(15%)、药学/药理学(8.8%)、癌症/肿瘤学(7.2%)、心血管系统(4.9%)、流行病学/公共卫生(4.5%)、内分泌学/代谢(4%)和神经科学/神经病学(4%)。与可引用项目对应的研究中,仅32%在该期刊出版地巴塞罗那开展,19.5%在马德里开展,近9%在安达卢西亚开展。约66%的文章和仅25%的信件至少被引用过一次,文章的平均引用次数为2.83次,信件为1.3次。与从其他国际SCI期刊收到的引用相比,同一期刊发表的其他文献的自引率很高(文章为77.8%)。《临床医学》中发现的参考文献模式与同类高排名期刊相似。将《临床医学》发表的文献与从SCI中检索到的文献进行比较,发现文献类型缺乏一致性。关于作者姓氏,除了SCI衍生的分类错误外,西班牙作者书目名称的异质性还带来了潜在问题。
《临床医学》似乎对广泛的作者、中心和主题开放。在《临床医学》中产出高的健康中心在其他国际期刊上产出也很高。期刊发表内容与该信息在SCI数据库中的索引方式之间的差异不仅对期刊的知名度构成重要障碍,也对全面检索作者的成果构成障碍。建议改变文献分类并在使用作者书目名称时采用一致标准。