Schwarz J, Tatsch K, Gasser T, Arnold G, Oertel W H
Department of Neurology, Klinikum Grosshadern, Ludwig-Maximilian University, Germany.
Mov Disord. 1997 Nov;12(6):898-902. doi: 10.1002/mds.870120610.
We investigated the cases of 55 patients with parkinsonism and prior dopaminomimetic therapy in whom the response to this treatment was questionable or reported to be negative. None of these patients had shown motor fluctuations prior to this study. We compared the results of imaging of dopamine-D2 receptors by using [123I]iodobenzamide-single-photon-emission computed tomography (IBZM-SPECT) with the improvement in motor signs following a subcutaneous injection of apomorphine and a subsequent increase in oral dopaminomimetic therapy. IBZM-SPECT accurately predicted a positive or negative response to apomorphine in 37 (84%) of 44 patients. The sensitivity/specificity was calculated as 96.3%/ 64.7%. The sensitivity/specificity of IBZM-SPECT for the response to oral treatment with levodopa (L-dopa) was calculated as 100%/75%. After a follow-up period of 2-4 years, 25 patients developed motor fluctuations. All of these patients had normal IBZM binding. Nine developed clinical signs indicating a basal ganglia disorder other than Parkinson's disease. Eight of these nine patients had reduced, and one patient had normal, IBZM binding. We conclude that normal IBZM binding is a useful predictor of a good response to dopaminergic drugs in patients with parkinsonism and a questionable response to previous dopaminomimetic therapy. Reduced IBZM binding seems to exclude a diagnosis of Parkinson's disease, because none of the latter patients clearly benefited from L-dopa and 66.7% developed clinical signs indicating another disorder of the basal ganglia.
我们调查了55例患有帕金森症且曾接受过拟多巴胺治疗的患者,这些患者对该治疗的反应存疑或据报告为阴性。在本研究之前,这些患者均未出现运动波动。我们将使用[123I]碘苄胺单光子发射计算机断层扫描(IBZM-SPECT)对多巴胺D2受体进行成像的结果,与皮下注射阿扑吗啡后运动体征的改善情况以及随后口服拟多巴胺治疗增加后的情况进行了比较。IBZM-SPECT准确预测了44例患者中37例(84%)对阿扑吗啡的阳性或阴性反应。敏感性/特异性计算为96.3%/64.7%。IBZM-SPECT对左旋多巴(L-dopa)口服治疗反应的敏感性/特异性计算为100%/75%。经过2至4年的随访期,25例患者出现了运动波动。所有这些患者的IBZM结合均正常。9例出现了表明除帕金森病之外的基底神经节疾病的临床体征。这9例患者中有8例IBZM结合减少,1例患者IBZM结合正常。我们得出结论,对于帕金森症患者且对先前拟多巴胺治疗反应存疑的情况,正常的IBZM结合是对多巴胺能药物有良好反应的有用预测指标。IBZM结合减少似乎可排除帕金森病的诊断,因为这些患者中没有一例从L-dopa中明显获益,且66.7%出现了表明基底神经节另一疾病的临床体征。