Bleyer W A, Tejeda H, Murphy S B, Robison L L, Ross J A, Pollock B H, Severson R K, Brawley O W, Smith M A, Ungerleider R S
Children's Cancer Group, Arcadia, California, USA.
J Adolesc Health. 1997 Dec;21(6):366-73. doi: 10.1016/S1054-139X(97)00110-9.
To determine whether adolescents with cancer, who in comparison to younger patients have a higher cancer incidence and lower mortality reduction, have equal access to national cancer clinical trials.
The ethnic/racial distribution of 29,859 subjects < 20 years of age entered onto National Cancer Institute-sponsored clinical trials between January 1, 1991, and June 30, 1994, was compared with the expected distribution of patients of the same age in the United States.
The Children's Cancer Group and Pediatric Oncology Group had 29,134 (97.6%) of the total study entries among < 20-year-old subjects during the 3.5 years of surveillance. The adult cooperative groups accounted for < 3% of the clinical trials entries in the 15-19-year age range. When analyzed nationally by region, the under-representation of the older adolescent subjects was universal. From other analyses, the two pediatric cooperative groups were estimated to have registered > 94% of the children < 15 years of age who were expected to have been diagnosed to have cancer, but only 21% of the cancer patients in the 15-19-year age group.
The national pediatric cancer cooperative groups allow the majority of American children < 15 years of age and their families equal opportunity to access clinical cancer trials, regardless of race or ethnicity. Among patients 15-19 years of age, however, > 75% are not being enrolled by any cooperative group sponsored by the National Cancer Institute. Thus, older adolescents are disadvantaged with respect to access to the national clinical trials, regardless of their race or ethnicity.
与较年轻的癌症患者相比,青少年癌症患者的癌症发病率较高且死亡率降低幅度较小,本研究旨在确定他们参与国家癌症临床试验的机会是否均等。
将1991年1月1日至1994年6月30日期间进入由美国国立癌症研究所赞助的临床试验的29859名20岁以下受试者的种族分布情况,与美国同年龄患者的预期分布进行比较。
在3.5年的监测期内,儿童癌症研究组和儿科肿瘤学组的研究对象占20岁以下受试者总数的29134名(97.6%)。成人协作组在15 - 19岁年龄组的临床试验参与者中占比不到3%。按地区进行全国性分析时,年龄较大的青少年受试者代表性不足的情况普遍存在。从其他分析来看,估计两个儿科协作组登记了预计被诊断患有癌症的15岁以下儿童的94%以上,但在15 - 19岁年龄组的癌症患者中仅占21%。
全国性的儿科癌症协作组为大多数15岁以下的美国儿童及其家庭提供了平等参与临床癌症试验的机会,无论其种族或民族如何。然而,在15 - 19岁的患者中,超过75%未被任何由美国国立癌症研究所赞助的协作组纳入。因此,年龄较大的青少年在参与国家临床试验方面处于不利地位,无论其种族或民族如何。