Giulianotti P C, Boggi U, Ferdeghini M, Di Candio G, Caravaglios G, Bellini R, Mosca F
Istituto di Chirurgia Generale e Sperimentale, Università degli Studi di Pisa.
Ann Ital Chir. 1997 May-Jun;68(3):307-13.
The aim of this study is to assess the clinical usefulness of the serum assay for CAR-3 in the diagnosis and follow-up of pancreatic cancer.
Serum levels of tumor markers (CAR-3, Ca 19.9, Ca 195 and CEA) were measured in a total of 238 patients with various diseases of the gastrointestinal (GI) tract, including 61 pancreatic cancers. Cut-off levels were calculated on the basis of a non-parametric estimate of 90% specificity. After surgery, patients with pancreatic cancer underwent a combined serological and radiological (CT-scan) follow-up.
At the cut-off level of 6.15 U/L, the sensitivity of CAR-3 was 62.3% (CA 19.9: 77%; Ca 195: 75.4%; CEA: 24.5%). In the differential diagnosis between pancreatic cancer and other GI diseases, significant differences were found. No association was discovered either between serum level of tumor markers and tumor stage or between short- and long-term survivors. In the follow-up, CT-scan was superior to serologic tests (sensitivity: 94.2%). Among tumor markers, CAR-3 achieved a sensitivity of 62.5% (Ca 19.9: 83.3%; Ca 195: 75%).
CAR-3 is shed in the circulating stream in a much lower proportion of cases than that observed for antigen expression at immunohistochemistry. During the follow-up CT-scan was the most accurate diagnostic tool. However, the meagre therapeutical options for recurrent pancreatic cancer, do not justify such an aggressive follow-up.
Ca 19.9 remains the tumor marker of choice for either the pre-operative work-up or the post-surgical follow-up of patients with pancreatic cancer.
本研究旨在评估血清检测癌胚抗原相关细胞黏附分子3(CAR-3)在胰腺癌诊断及随访中的临床应用价值。
共检测了238例患有各种胃肠道疾病的患者的血清肿瘤标志物水平(CAR-3、癌抗原19-9(Ca 19.9)、癌抗原195(Ca 195)和癌胚抗原(CEA)),其中包括61例胰腺癌患者。根据90%特异性的非参数估计计算临界值。胰腺癌患者术后接受血清学和影像学(CT扫描)联合随访。
在临界值为6.15 U/L时,CAR-3的灵敏度为62.3%(Ca 19.9为77%;Ca 195为75.4%;CEA为24.5%)。在胰腺癌与其他胃肠道疾病的鉴别诊断中发现了显著差异。未发现肿瘤标志物血清水平与肿瘤分期之间以及短期和长期存活者之间存在关联。在随访中,CT扫描优于血清学检测(灵敏度:94.2%)。在肿瘤标志物中,CAR-3的灵敏度为62.5%(Ca 19.9为83.3%;Ca 195为75%)。
与免疫组化观察到的抗原表达情况相比,CAR-3在循环血液中的释放比例要低得多。在随访期间,CT扫描是最准确的诊断工具。然而,复发性胰腺癌的治疗选择有限,因此没有必要进行如此积极的随访。
Ca 19.9仍然是胰腺癌患者术前检查或术后随访的首选肿瘤标志物。