Ceriani L, Giovanella L, Bandera M, Beghe B, Ortelli M, Roncari G
Department of Nuclear Medicine, University Hospital, Varese, Italy.
Nucl Med Commun. 1997 Nov;18(11):1087-97. doi: 10.1097/00006231-199711000-00013.
The objectives of this study were to measure semi-quantitatively uptake of 99Tcm-sestamibi (99Tcm-MIBI) by tumour tissue in patients with lung cancer and to investigate its relationship with clinical response to chemotherapy. 99Tcm-MIBI single photon emission tomography was performed at the time of diagnosis in 31 patients with biopsy-proven lung cancer (19 small cell carcinomas, 12 non-small cell carcinomas), all of whom were undergoing chemotherapy. Fifteen patients were also investigated 2 weeks after the first and third cycles of chemotherapy. To quantify 99Tcm-MIBI uptake, a tumour/lung (T/L) ratio was calculated for the tomographic slices. The response to chemotherapy was rated as complete remission, partial remission or no remission using dimensional criteria. The results were expressed as the median and inter-quartile range; non-parametric statistical analyses were used. Forty one neoplastic localizations (31 primary tumours and 10 hilar or mediastinal lymph node masses) were assessed. The median T/L ratio of the primary tumours was 1.85 (range 1.7-2.4). Patients with a different response to chemotherapy had a significantly different median T/L ratio before chemotherapy: complete remission (n = 8), T/L ratio = 2.95 (range 2.20-3.25); partial remission (n = 10), 2.15 (range 1.77-2.40); no remission (n = 13), 1.70 (range 1.47-1.75) (Kruskal-Wallis, P < 0.0001). A T/L ratio of 1.80 gave sensitivity of 83%, specificity of 85% and accuracy of 84% in the prediction of the response to chemotherapy. The patients with small cell carcinomas demonstrated greater 99Tcm-MIBI uptake than those with non-small cell carcinomas: T/L ratio, median 2.30 (range 1.76-3.00) vs 1.70 (range 1.50-1.78) (Mann-Whitney U-test, P = 0.001). No significant difference in 99Tcm-MIBI uptake was observed between the 10 lymph node metastases and the corresponding primary tumours: T/L ratio, median 2.30 (range 1.75-2.50) vs 2.15 (1.77-3.00) (Wilcoxon's paired samples rank test, N.S.). Of the 15 patients who were monitored with scintigraphy during chemotherapy, 10 showed complete or partial remission and a parallel reduction in their T/L ratio. The other five patients showed no response to chemotherapy and their T/L ratio was either unaffected or increased. We conclude that the semi-quantitative assessment of 99Tcm-MIBI uptake may have a significant role to play in the management of lung cancer, providing an effective means of predicting the efficacy of chemotherapy and of selecting subgroups of patients requiring radiotherapy or combined protocols before the start of treatment. 99Tcm-MIBI imaging may also be of use in monitoring clinical response to chemotherapy.
本研究的目的是对肺癌患者肿瘤组织摄取99锝-甲氧基异丁基异腈(99Tcm-MIBI)进行半定量测量,并研究其与化疗临床反应的关系。对31例经活检证实为肺癌的患者(19例小细胞癌,12例非小细胞癌)在诊断时进行了99Tcm-MIBI单光子发射断层扫描,所有患者均正在接受化疗。其中15例患者在化疗的第一周期和第三周期后2周也进行了检查。为了量化99Tcm-MIBI摄取,计算断层扫描切片的肿瘤/肺(T/L)比值。使用维度标准将化疗反应评定为完全缓解、部分缓解或无缓解。结果以中位数和四分位间距表示;采用非参数统计分析。评估了41个肿瘤定位(31个原发性肿瘤和10个肺门或纵隔淋巴结肿块)。原发性肿瘤的中位T/L比值为1.85(范围1.7 - 2.4)。化疗反应不同的患者化疗前的中位T/L比值有显著差异:完全缓解(n = 8),T/L比值 = 2.95(范围2.20 - 3.25);部分缓解(n = 10),2.15(范围1.77 - 2.40);无缓解(n = 13),1.70(范围1.47 - 1.75)(Kruskal-Wallis检验,P < 0.0001)。T/L比值为1.80时,预测化疗反应的敏感性为83%,特异性为85%,准确性为84%。小细胞癌患者的99Tcm-MIBI摄取高于非小细胞癌患者:T/L比值,中位值2.30(范围1.76 - 3.00)对1.70(范围1.50 - 1.78)(Mann-Whitney U检验,P = 0.001)。在10个淋巴结转移灶与其相应原发性肿瘤之间未观察到99Tcm-MIBI摄取有显著差异:T/L比值,中位值2.30(范围1.75 - 2.50)对2.15(1.77 - 3.00)(Wilcoxon配对样本秩和检验,无显著性差异)。在化疗期间接受闪烁扫描监测的15例患者中,10例显示完全或部分缓解,其T/L比值同时降低。另外5例患者对化疗无反应,其T/L比值未受影响或升高。我们得出结论,99Tcm-MIBI摄取的半定量评估在肺癌管理中可能发挥重要作用,为预测化疗疗效以及在治疗开始前选择需要放疗或联合方案的患者亚组提供了一种有效方法。99Tcm-MIBI成像也可用于监测化疗的临床反应。