Heyns C F, van Vollenhoven P, Steenkamp J W, Allen F J
Department of Urology, University of Stellenbosch, Tygerberg, W. Cape.
S Afr J Surg. 1997 Aug;35(3):120-4.
We reviewed the management of 50 patients with cancer of the penis treated between November 1983 and April 1995 at Tygerberg Hospital. The mean patient age was 54 years. The race of the patient was mixed in 40, white in 8 and black in 2 cases. Serological tests were positive for syphilis in 8/18 (44%), and for human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) in 2/11 patients (18%) who were tested. Only 1 patient had been circumcised (at puberty). Penectomy was performed in 45 patients--partial amputation in 29 cases and radical penectomy in 20 (in 4 of these after previous partial penectomy with positive margins). Complications of penectomy occurred in 9 patients (20%). The histology of the primary lesion was squamous carcinoma in 46, verrucous carcinoma in 3 and melanoma in 1 patient. Differentiation of the tumour was good in 24, moderate in 15 and poor in 8; the grade was not recorded in 3 cases. The pathological T stage was Tis in 1 patient, T1 in 5, T2 in 24, T3 in 17 and T4 in 3 cases. Inguinal lymphadenectomy was performed in 34 patients at a median interval of 72 days after penectomy. Complications after lymphadenectomy occurred in 26 of the 34 patients (76%), but a second operation was required in only 5 cases (15%). In patients without clinically palpable inguinal nodes, cancer was present in 2/8 (25%) specimens. In patients with clinically palpable inguinal nodes, metastases were present in 16/29 (55%)--in 4/16 (25%) of nodes clinically thought to be infective, and in 12/13 (92%) of nodes considered to be malignant. Lymph node metastases were present in 0/2 patients with T1, in 5/19 (26%) with T2, in 12/15 (80%) with T3 and in 3/3 (100%) with T4 tumours. At a mean follow-up of 22 months in 39 patients 62% were alive without evidence of disease, 23% were alive with carcinoma and 15% were dead. Death and recurrence or metastases were significantly more common in patients with T3-4 compared with T1-2 tumours, and in those with N1-3 compared to NO disease, but tumour grade had no significant effect on outcome. Death and recurrence or metastases were also more common in cases where the surgical margin at penectomy was involved with tumour. In conclusion, our patients presented at a relatively young age with locally advanced tumours and a high incidence of inguinal lymph node metastases. In patients with locally advanced tumours we recommend ablative surgery with bilateral inguinal lymphadenectomy 6-8 weeks after penectomy. We avoid pelvic lymph node dissection, since this does not improve the prognosis, while increasing the risk of complications, especially lower limb oedema.
我们回顾了1983年11月至1995年4月期间在泰格堡医院接受治疗的50例阴茎癌患者的治疗情况。患者的平均年龄为54岁。患者种族构成如下:40例为混合种族,8例为白人,2例为黑人。18例患者中8例(44%)梅毒血清学检测呈阳性,11例接受检测的患者中有2例(18%)人类免疫缺陷病毒(HIV)检测呈阳性。仅1例患者(青春期时)接受过包皮环切术。45例患者接受了阴茎切除术——29例行部分切除术,20例行根治性阴茎切除术(其中4例是在先前部分阴茎切除术后切缘阳性的情况下进行的根治性切除)。9例患者(20%)出现了阴茎切除术后并发症。原发灶组织学类型为鳞状细胞癌46例,疣状癌3例,黑色素瘤1例。肿瘤分化良好者24例,中等分化者15例,低分化者8例;3例未记录分级情况。病理T分期:Tis期1例,T1期5例,T2期24例,T3期17例,T4期3例。34例患者在阴茎切除术后中位间隔72天接受了腹股沟淋巴结清扫术。34例患者中有26例(76%)出现了淋巴结清扫术后并发症,但仅5例(15%)需要再次手术。在无临床可触及腹股沟淋巴结的患者中,8例标本中有2例(25%)存在癌转移。在有临床可触及腹股沟淋巴结的患者中,29例中有16例(55%)出现转移——临床认为有感染的淋巴结中4例(25%)出现转移,认为是恶性的淋巴结中13例中有12例(92%)出现转移。T1期2例患者均无淋巴结转移,T2期19例中有5例(26%)出现转移,T3期15例中有12例(80%)出现转移,T4期3例均出现转移(100%)。39例患者平均随访22个月,62%存活且无疾病证据,23%带癌存活,15%死亡。与T1 - 2期肿瘤患者相比,T3 - 4期患者死亡、复发或转移明显更常见;与无淋巴结转移(N0)的患者相比,有淋巴结转移(N1 - 3)的患者上述情况也更常见,但肿瘤分级对预后无显著影响。阴茎切除时手术切缘受累的病例中,死亡、复发或转移也更常见。总之,我们的患者发病年龄相对较轻,局部肿瘤进展期,腹股沟淋巴结转移发生率高。对于局部进展期肿瘤患者,我们建议在阴茎切除术后6 - 8周进行双侧腹股沟淋巴结清扫的根治性手术。我们避免进行盆腔淋巴结清扫,因为这并不能改善预后,反而会增加并发症风险,尤其是下肢水肿。