Murray D J, Forbes R B, Titone M B, Weinstein S L
Department of Anesthesia, Washington University School of Medicine at St. Louis Children's Hospital, USA.
Spine (Phila Pa 1976). 1997 Dec 1;22(23):2735-40. doi: 10.1097/00007632-199712010-00007.
A retrospective review of consecutive pediatric and adolescent patients who required posterior spinal fusion to correct scoliosis.
To 1) measure the participation of pediatric patients in predeposit programs for autologous and directed blood donation 2) to assess the success of autologous predonation in preventing allogeneic blood use, 3) to determine whether transfusion indications differed between patients who received allogeneic blood and those who received autologous blood, and 4) to assess factors that predict transfusion requirements during scoliosis surgery.
Authors of recent studies in adults have questioned whether transfusion of autologous blood is a cost-effective therapy when compared with the less-expensive alternative--transfusion of allogeneic blood. In children, the efficacy of autologous blood has not been assessed in a large population of surgical patients. In adults, the frequency of patient participation, the success of autologous donors in avoiding allogeneic transfusion, and the proportion of collected autologous units used during the perioperative period are measures used to establish the efficacy of autologous predonation programs.
Hospital and clinic records for each patient who underwent posterior spinal fusion from September 1, 1989 through September 1, 1994 were reviewed. Blood bank consultation, autologous donation records, anesthesia records, surgical reports, and hospital records were reviewed. Seventy percent of patients (164 of 243) participated in autologous donation.
More than 90% of autologous donors successfully avoided receiving allogeneic blood. Patients with idiopathic scoliosis (n = 168) were more likely to participate in autologous donation (n = 144) and to avoid allogeneic blood (n = 135). Patients with neurologic causes of scoliosis more commonly used allogeneic or directed donation (56 of 75 patients). Nineteen patients with neuromuscular causes of scoliosis participated in autologous donation, but more than one half of this group (10 of 19 patients) required allogeneic blood in addition to autologous units.
Using measures of efficacy similar to those reported in studies of adults, autologous blood was found to be more effective in meeting the transfusion needs of pediatric patients who required posterior spinal fusion than in meeting those needs in adult surgical patients in previous studies.
对连续接受后路脊柱融合术矫正脊柱侧弯的儿童和青少年患者进行回顾性研究。
1)衡量儿科患者参与自体和定向献血预存项目的情况;2)评估自体预存献血在避免异体输血方面的成效;3)确定接受异体血和接受自体血的患者之间输血指征是否存在差异;4)评估预测脊柱侧弯手术期间输血需求的因素。
近期针对成人的研究作者质疑,与成本较低的异体输血相比,自体输血是否具有成本效益。在儿童群体中,尚未在大量外科手术患者中评估自体血的疗效。在成人中,患者参与度、自体献血者避免异体输血的成功率以及围手术期所采集的自体血单位的使用比例是用于确定自体预存献血项目疗效的指标。
回顾了1989年9月1日至1994年9月1日期间接受后路脊柱融合术的每位患者的医院和诊所记录。查阅了血库咨询记录、自体献血记录、麻醉记录、手术报告和医院记录。70%的患者(243例中的164例)参与了自体献血。
超过90%的自体献血者成功避免接受异体血。特发性脊柱侧弯患者(n = 168)更有可能参与自体献血(n = 144)并避免接受异体血(n = 135)。因神经原因导致脊柱侧弯的患者更常使用异体血或定向献血(75例患者中的56例)。19例因神经肌肉原因导致脊柱侧弯的患者参与了自体献血,但该组中超过一半(19例患者中的10例)除自体血单位外还需要异体血。
采用与成人研究中报告的类似疗效指标,发现自体血在满足接受后路脊柱融合术的儿科患者的输血需求方面比在以往研究中满足成人外科手术患者的需求更有效。