Walker B F, Buchbinder R
Department of Public Health and Tropical Medicine, James Cook University, Townsville, Queensland, Australia.
J Manipulative Physiol Ther. 1997 Nov-Dec;20(9):583-9.
To determine the most commonly used diagnostic methods for detecting the spinal entity that chiropractors adjust/manipulate and the preferred term for describing this entity.
Postal survey (self-completed questionnaire).
Victoria, Australia.
All 554 chiropractors registered May 30, 1994, with the Chiropractors and Osteopaths Registration Board of Victoria.
Frequency of use and opinion with respect to reliability of 16 specific methods, measured on a 7-point, Likert-type scale [never used (1) to always used (7) and very unreliable (1) to very reliable (7), respectively]; the respondent's preferred term for describing the spinal entity that chiropractors adjust/manipulate.
The response rate was 85%. The most commonly used method was static palpation (mean score 6.6 +/- 1.1). Seven other methods, including pain description of the patient, orthopedic tests, motion palpation, visual posture analysis, leg length discrepancy, neurological tests and plain static X-rays had mean scores greater than 4.0. All of these methods, as well as functional X-ray views and kinesiological muscle testing, were considered reliable, with mean reliability scores greater than 4.0. Motion palpation was regarded as the most reliable method (mean reliability score 5.9 +/- 1.2). Seventy-five different terms for describing the spinal entity were named by 440 respondents. "Subluxation" was included in the preferred term of 294 respondents (67%), 46 included "dysfunction" (11%), 35 included "fixation" (8%) and 20 included "manipulable" (4.5%).
Chiropractors commonly use a variety of methods to identify the spinal entity that they manipulate. There is no consensus as to the preferred term for describing this entity.
确定用于检测脊椎按摩师进行调整/手法治疗的脊椎病变的最常用诊断方法,以及描述该病变的首选术语。
邮寄调查(自行填写问卷)。
澳大利亚维多利亚州。
1994年5月30日在维多利亚州脊椎按摩师与整骨疗法注册委员会注册的所有554名脊椎按摩师。
16种特定方法的使用频率和关于可靠性的意见,分别采用7分制李克特量表进行测量[从不使用(1)至总是使用(7),以及非常不可靠(1)至非常可靠(7)];受访者描述脊椎按摩师进行调整/手法治疗的脊椎病变的首选术语。
回复率为85%。最常用的方法是静态触诊(平均得分6.6±1.1)。其他七种方法,包括患者的疼痛描述、骨科检查、动态触诊、视觉姿势分析、腿长差异、神经学检查和平片静态X线检查,平均得分均大于4.0。所有这些方法,以及功能X线片和运动学肌肉测试,均被认为是可靠的,平均可靠性得分大于4.0。动态触诊被视为最可靠的方法(平均可靠性得分5.9±1.2)。440名受访者列出了75个不同的术语来描述脊椎病变。“半脱位”被294名受访者(67%)列入首选术语,46名(11%)列入“功能障碍”,35名(8%)列入“固定”,20名(4.5%)列入“可手法治疗的”。
脊椎按摩师通常使用多种方法来识别他们进行手法治疗的脊椎病变。对于描述该病变的首选术语尚无共识。