Griffiths T D, Sigmundsson T, Takei N, Frangou S, Birkett P B, Sharma T, Reveley A M, Murray R M
Wellcome Department of Cognitive Neurology, Institute of Neurology, London, UK.
J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry. 1998 Jan;64(1):56-60. doi: 10.1136/jnnp.64.1.56.
(1) To test the hypothesis that minor physical anomalies are increased in patients with schizophrenia and (2) to investigate differences in the prevalence of minor physical anomalies in patients with familial and sporadic schizophrenia and their first degree relatives.
A weighted Waldrop assessment was carried out on 214 subjects in five groups: schizophrenic patients from multiply affected families; first degree relatives of these familial schizophrenic patients; sporadic schizophrenic patients; first degree relatives of these sporadic schizophrenic patients, and normal controls. Broad and narrow criteria for abnormality were defined based on the distribution of minor physical anomalies in the control group.
(1) The total schizophrenic group did not have a significant increase in minor physical anomalies using a narrow criterion of abnormality, but did when a broader criterion was used. (2) A significant increase in the proportion of subjects with an abnormally high number of minor physical abnormalities was shown in the group of sporadic schizophrenic patients (uncorrected p<0.01). Separate analyses for males and females showed a significant increase in the male sporadic group (uncorrected p<0.05), and a smaller non-significant increase in the female sporadic group. Neither the familial schizophrenic group nor either group of first degree relatives showed any significant increases in the proportion of patients with high abnormality scores.
This work supports prenatal developmental abnormality as a mechanism for sporadic, but not familial, schizophrenia.
(1)检验精神分裂症患者轻微躯体异常增加的假设;(2)调查家族性和散发性精神分裂症患者及其一级亲属中轻微躯体异常患病率的差异。
对五组共214名受试者进行加权沃尔德罗普评估:来自多例患者家庭的精神分裂症患者;这些家族性精神分裂症患者的一级亲属;散发性精神分裂症患者;这些散发性精神分裂症患者的一级亲属,以及正常对照组。根据对照组中轻微躯体异常的分布情况定义了宽泛和严格的异常标准。
(1)使用严格的异常标准时,精神分裂症患者总体的轻微躯体异常没有显著增加,但使用宽泛标准时则有增加。(2)散发性精神分裂症患者组中轻微躯体异常数量异常高的受试者比例显著增加(未校正p<0.01)。对男性和女性分别进行分析显示,男性散发性患者组有显著增加(未校正p<0.05),女性散发性患者组有较小的、不显著的增加。家族性精神分裂症患者组及其一级亲属组中,异常得分高的患者比例均未显示出任何显著增加。
这项研究支持产前发育异常是散发性而非家族性精神分裂症的一种机制。