Robertson J F, Willsher P C, Cheung K L, Blamey R W
City Hospital, Nottingham, U.K.
Eur J Cancer. 1997 Oct;33(11):1774-9. doi: 10.1016/s0959-8049(97)00178-0.
This study reports on the clinical relevance of the static disease (SD) category in 255 breast cancer patients on endocrine therapy. All patients had received first- and second-line endocrine therapy and were assessed for response by the International Union Against Cancer (UICC) criteria. We did not include patients who received first-line endocrine therapy but did not or have not yet proceeded to second-line hormone therapy, e.g. died from rapidly progressive disease, started chemotherapy for rapidly progressive disease, remained in long-term remission on first-line endocrine therapy. We analysed survival from initiation of first-line endocrine therapy by the remission criteria, i.e. complete response (CR), partial response (PR), static disease (SD) or progressive disease (PD), achieved on that therapy. Patients were divided into those with metastatic breast cancer (MBC) and non-metastatic disease. There was no significant difference in survival from starting first-line endocrine therapy between patients who obtained CR, PR or SD: all three groups of patients survived significantly longer than patients who showed PD within 6 months (all P < 0.0001 except CR versus PD [MBC] which was P < 0.002). Equally, for second-line endocrine therapy there was no difference in survival between patients who obtained CR, PR or SD: all three groups (CR, PR and SD) survived significantly longer than PD (all P < 0.0003 except for CR versus PD which was P < 0.003 for non-metastatic and P < 0.059 for MBC). Durable SD appears to be a clinically useful criteria of therapeutic remission.
本研究报告了255例接受内分泌治疗的乳腺癌患者中静态疾病(SD)分类的临床相关性。所有患者均接受了一线和二线内分泌治疗,并根据国际抗癌联盟(UICC)标准评估反应。我们未纳入那些接受一线内分泌治疗但未或尚未进行二线激素治疗的患者,例如因疾病快速进展死亡、因疾病快速进展开始化疗、在一线内分泌治疗中保持长期缓解的患者。我们根据该治疗所达到的缓解标准,即完全缓解(CR)、部分缓解(PR)、静态疾病(SD)或疾病进展(PD),分析了从一线内分泌治疗开始后的生存情况。患者被分为转移性乳腺癌(MBC)和非转移性疾病患者。获得CR、PR或SD的患者从开始一线内分泌治疗后的生存情况无显著差异:所有这三组患者的生存期均显著长于在6个月内出现PD的患者(除CR与PD[MBC]比较P<0.002外,所有P<0.0001)。同样,对于二线内分泌治疗,获得CR、PR或SD的患者生存情况也无差异:所有三组(CR、PR和SD)的生存期均显著长于PD(除CR与PD比较外,非转移性疾病的P<0.003,MBC的P<0.059,所有P<0.0003)。持久的SD似乎是治疗缓解的一个临床有用标准。