Marsden C D
Institute of Neurology, London, England.
Drugs. 1998;55 Suppl 1:17-22. doi: 10.2165/00003495-199855001-00003.
The clinical efficacy of the long-acting dopamine agonist cabergoline as an adjunct to levodopa has been investigated in controlled and uncontrolled studies in > 1500 patients with advanced Parkinson's disease and motor complications. Four of these studies (including 2 comparisons with placebo and 2 with bromocriptine), which used similar methodology (including study design, blindness, selection criteria, treatment modalities and duration) and measurements of efficacy and safety, are reviewed. Compared with placebo, cabergoline 2 to 10 mg/day (median 5 mg/day) induced a significantly higher percentage decrease in the number of 'off' hours (18 vs 45%) in a preliminary phase II study that included 37 patients with severe motor fluctuations. This was not associated with an increase in dyskinesia in either treatment group. In a subsequent phase III placebo-controlled study (n = 188 patients with motor fluctuations), treatment with cabergoline 0.5 to 5 mg/day (median 3.5 mg/day) achieved a statistically significant decrease in levodopa dosage compared with placebo (18 vs 3%) and improved the Unified Parkinson's Disease Rating Scale scores for activities of daily living in a greater number of patients (23 vs 4%). Comparisons of cabergoline with bromocriptine have been conducted in 750 patients stabilised on levodopa therapy; one study was conducted in patients without, and the other in patients with, previous exposure to dopamine agonists. Cabergoline was administered once daily at doses ranging from 0.5 to 6 mg, and bromocriptine was given at a dosage of 5 to 40 mg/day divided into 3 administrations. A combined analysis of the response rates obtained in the 2 studies found cabergoline to be at least as effective and well tolerated as bromocriptine, with a trend in favour of cabergoline in terms of response rate and number of 'off' hours. The majority of adverse events in this patient population were those associated with levodopa therapy, as shown by the high frequency of adverse events in the placebo group (68%). Both cabergoline and bromocriptine showed a comparable incidence of adverse events, with CNS and gastrointestinal events being the most common. Thus, the potential advantages of cabergoline include improved patient compliance as a result of its once-daily administration, and an increased threshold for the development of dyskinesia as a result of the levodopa sparing effect of cabergoline.
长效多巴胺激动剂卡麦角林作为左旋多巴辅助药物的临床疗效,已在1500多名晚期帕金森病及运动并发症患者中进行了对照和非对照研究。本文回顾了其中四项研究(包括两项与安慰剂比较以及两项与溴隐亭比较的研究),这些研究采用了相似的方法(包括研究设计、盲法、选择标准、治疗方式及持续时间)以及疗效和安全性测量指标。在一项纳入37例严重运动波动患者的II期初步研究中,与安慰剂相比,卡麦角林2至10毫克/天(中位数为5毫克/天)使“关”期时间的减少百分比显著更高(分别为18%和45%)。两个治疗组的异动症均未增加。在随后一项III期安慰剂对照研究(n = 188例有运动波动的患者)中,与安慰剂相比,卡麦角林0.5至5毫克/天(中位数为3.5毫克/天)治疗使左旋多巴剂量有统计学意义的显著降低(分别为18%和3%),并且更多患者的帕金森病统一评分量表日常生活活动得分得到改善(分别为23%和4%)。已在750例稳定接受左旋多巴治疗的患者中对卡麦角林与溴隐亭进行了比较;一项研究针对未曾接触过多巴胺激动剂的患者,另一项针对曾接触过多巴胺激动剂的患者。卡麦角林每日给药一次,剂量范围为0.5至6毫克,溴隐亭剂量为5至40毫克/天,分3次给药。对两项研究获得的缓解率进行综合分析发现,卡麦角林至少与溴隐亭疗效相当且耐受性良好,在缓解率和“关”期时间方面有支持卡麦角林的趋势。该患者群体中的大多数不良事件是与左旋多巴治疗相关的事件,如安慰剂组中不良事件的高发生率所示(68%)。卡麦角林和溴隐亭的不良事件发生率相当,中枢神经系统和胃肠道事件最为常见。因此,卡麦角林的潜在优势包括每日一次给药提高了患者依从性,以及由于卡麦角林的左旋多巴节省效应使异动症发生阈值提高。