Swindle P, Falk M, Rigby R, Petrie J, Hawley C, Nicol D
Department of Urology, Princess Alexandra Hospital, Brisbane, Australia.
Br J Urol. 1998 Feb;81(2):229-33. doi: 10.1046/j.1464-410x.1998.00496.x.
To determine the incidence of transitional cell carcinoma (TCC) in a renal transplant population and to compare the pattern of neoplasia in patients with analgesic nephropathy (AN) with that in other patients.
Using the Australia and New Zealand Dialysis and Transplant Registry, renal transplant recipients of the Princess Alexandra Hospital with TCC were identified. They were separated into two groups based on their primary disease, i.e. AN (group 1) and other causes of renal failure (group 2). The age at diagnosis of TCC, site, grade, stage of TCC and outcome were then compared between the groups.
There were 250 (15%) patients in group 1 and 1424 (85%) in group 2; seven patients in each group were found to have TCC, which thus occurred more frequently in the AN group (2.8%) than in group 2 (0.49%). In group 1, five patients died, four from metastatic disease; of these, the mean time from transplantation to diagnosis of the initial tumour was 4.4 years, with a mean time from diagnosis to death of 9 months. In contrast, there were no deaths from metastatic disease in group 2. In group 1, all patients had upper tract tumours, with five patients also having bladder involvement. The upper tract tumours tended to be of a high stage and grade (grade II-III) and were aggressive. In group 2, all the tumours were confined to the bladder and tended to be of low stage and grade (grade I-II Ta).
Patients undergoing renal transplantation as a result of AN are at high risk of developing TCCs of the upper urinary tracts. These tumours tend to be of a high grade and stage and the patients have a poor outcome. Screening with urine analysis and voided urine cytology do not appear to be reliable for the early diagnosis of upper renal tract TCCs in the renal transplant patient. We advocate annual cystoscopy and retrograde ureteric catheterization with washings, brushings and radiological imaging to diagnose upper tract TCCs at an early stage. These patients should also be screened before transplantation using the same technique.
