Musatov M I, Petrova E D, Konenkov V I
Institute of Clinical Immunology, Siberian Branch of the Academy of Medical Sciences, Novosibirsk.
Tsitologiia. 1997;39(7):617-28.
It has been presumed that: 1) rheumatoid arthritis (RA) is a genuine model of activation of the peripheral natural killers (NK); 2) methods of NK separation can cause their activation, and therefore only peripheral mononuclear cells were used. The aim of this research was to study the role of cytolysis of HLA-I, HLA-DR, and costimulatory proteins CD11a and CD16 expressed on resting and activated peripheral NK cells. A total of 74 healthy volunteers (HV) and 74 RA patients were compared before corticosteroid or gold treatment. Two-colour immunofluorescence and cytofluorimetric analysis, cytotoxic test against the target K 562 cells (class I negative) before and after incubation of PMC with monoclonal antibodies (MoAB) to HLA-I (E3D8), HLA-DR (ICO-1), CD11 (ICO-11), PXx63 Ag8.653 as control, and also incubation with recombinant alpha 2-IFN were used. VEP-13 MoAB was used for CD16 determination. Compared with HV PMC, the RA PMC showed a statistically significant increase of activated NK lymphocytes (CD11a+DR+ and CD16+DR+ by 2.03 and 1.96 times, resp.), and increased level of expression of HLA-I, HLA-DR, and CD16 on CD11a+ lymphocytes, resulting in significantly diminished cytolytic activity (CA) by 1.9 times. A short-term incubation with alpha 2-IFN (100 U/ml, 1 h) increased the level of expression of HLA- and costimulatory proteins and the CA of the HV PMC, while the RA PMC did not react. HV peripheral NK are concluded to be mainly resting cells, and the RA peripheral NK are mainly the activated ones. Only using the level of expression of HLA-DR on CD11a lymphocytes, as a ranking criterion, allowed to reveal two types of correlation between the CA and immunocytological parameters of PMC. The first type: in HV, the CA correlated positively (P < 0.025) with the percentage of CD11a+CD16+, and with levels of expression of HLA-I (P < 0.025) and CD16 (P < 0.025) expressed on CD11a lymphocytes (5-9.5 MFI DR--the mean fluorescence intensity of HLA-DR). The second type: the CA positively correlated (P < 0.05) with the percentage of CD11a+CD16-, and with levels of expression of HLA-DR (P < 0.05) and CD11a (P < 0.05) expressed on CD11a lymphocytes (12.4-16 MFI DR). In RA patients with a "normal" density expression of HLA-DR on CD11a lymphocytes (up to 14 MFI) there exists a mixed type: the CA correlated positively (P < 0.05) with the percentage of CD11a+CD16+, and with levels of expression of HLA-DR (P < 0.05) and CD11a (P < 0.05) expressed on CD11a lymphocytes. In RA patients with a very high density expression of HLA-DR on CD11a lymphocytes (VH-DR group, 18-26 MFI) the CA correlated negatively with the percentage of CD11a+CD1 6+ (P < 0.05), and with levels of expression of HLA-DR (P < 0.025) and CD11a (P < 0.025) expressed on CD11a lymphocytes. The anti-HLA-I,-DR, -CD11a MoABs strongly inhibit the Ca in HV- and RA-PMC. However, in the VH-DR group the anti-DR MoAB stimulates the CA from 27.06 +/- 10.25 up to 41.69 +/- 14.23%. Thus, activated peripheral CD11a+CD16+ lymphocytes suppress the CA of other NK.
1)类风湿性关节炎(RA)是外周自然杀伤细胞(NK)激活的真实模型;2)NK分离方法可导致其激活,因此仅使用外周单核细胞。本研究的目的是研究静止和激活的外周NK细胞上表达的HLA - I、HLA - DR以及共刺激蛋白CD11a和CD16的细胞溶解作用。在进行皮质类固醇或金制剂治疗前,对74名健康志愿者(HV)和74名RA患者进行了比较。采用双色免疫荧光和细胞荧光分析、在用针对HLA - I(E3D8)、HLA - DR(ICO - 1)、CD11(ICO - 11)的单克隆抗体(MoAB)以及作为对照的PXx63 Ag8.653孵育PMC前后,对靶K 562细胞(I类阴性)进行细胞毒性试验,同时也进行了与重组α2 - IFN的孵育。VEP - 13 MoAB用于CD16的测定。与HV的PMC相比,RA的PMC显示活化的NK淋巴细胞有统计学显著增加(CD11a + DR +和CD16 + DR +分别增加2.03倍和1.96倍),并且CD11a +淋巴细胞上HLA - I、HLA - DR和CD16的表达水平增加,导致细胞溶解活性(CA)显著降低1.9倍。用α2 - IFN(100 U/ml,1小时)进行短期孵育可增加HV的PMC上HLA和共刺激蛋白的表达水平以及CA,而RA的PMC无反应。得出结论:HV外周NK主要是静止细胞,而RA外周NK主要是活化细胞。仅将CD11a淋巴细胞上HLA - DR的表达水平作为分级标准,就能够揭示PMC的CA与免疫细胞参数之间的两种相关性。第一种类型:在HV中,CA与CD11a + CD16 +的百分比以及CD11a淋巴细胞上表达的HLA - I水平(P < 0.025)和CD16水平(P < 0.025)呈正相关(5 - 9.5 MFI DR - HLA - DR的平均荧光强度)。第二种类型:CA与CD11a + CD16 -的百分比以及CD11a淋巴细胞上表达的HLA - DR水平(P < 0.05)和CD11a水平(P < 0.05)呈正相关(12.4 - 16 MFI DR)。在CD11a淋巴细胞上HLA - DR表达密度“正常”(高达14 MFI)的RA患者中存在混合型:CA与CD11a + CD16 +的百分比以及CD11a淋巴细胞上表达的HLA - DR水平(P < 0.05)和CD11a水平(P < 0.05)呈正相关。在CD11a淋巴细胞上HLA - DR表达密度非常高的RA患者(VH - DR组,18 - 26 MFI)中,CA与CD11a + CD16 +的百分比(P < 0.05)以及CD11a淋巴细胞上表达的HLA - DR水平(P < 0.025)和CD11a水平(P < 0.025)呈负相关。抗HLA - I、- DR、- CD11a的MoAB强烈抑制HV -和RA - PMC中的Ca。然而,在VH - DR组中,抗DR的MoAB将CA从27.06±10.25%刺激至41.