Wilson A M, McFarlane L C, Lipworth B J
Department of Clinical Pharmacology and Respiratory Medicine, Ninewells Hospital and Medical School, University of Dundee, Scotland.
J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 1998 Mar;83(3):922-5. doi: 10.1210/jcem.83.3.4637.
The objective of this study was to evaluate the effects of inhaled flunisolide (FN) and triamcinolone acetonide (TAA) on basal and dynamic adrenocortical activity. A randomized cross-over design was used, comparing placebo (PL), low (L) and high (H) doses of FN (Aerobid; 250 microg/actuation; without spacer; L, 1000 microg; H, 2000 microg/day), and TAA (Azmacort; 100 microg/actuation; with integrated actuator/spacer; L, 800 microg; H, 1600 microg/day). Each dose was given at 0800 and 2200 h for 3 days, and treatments were separated by a 10-day washout. Twelve normal volunteers (mean +/- SE age, 24.2 +/- 2.4 yr) were studied. After 3 days of treatment, blood samples were taken before ACTH stimulation at 0800 h (10 h after the sixth dose) and after ACTH (0.5 microg) stimulation for determination of serum cortisol. Overnight (starting at 2200 h on the third day of treatment) and early morning urine collections were taken for measurements of urinary cortisol corrected for creatinine excretion. For serum cortisol (pre- and post-ACTH stimulation), there was no significant difference compared with placebo for either drug. Post-ACTH cortisol (nanomoles per L) values were: PL, 666.3; H FN, 617.0; H TAA, 591.4; L FN, 699.2; and L TAA, 686.0. For overnight corrected urinary cortisol/creatinine excretion (nanomoles per mmol) compared with PL (6.4), there was a significant suppression (P < 0.05) at the high dose of both drugs (H FN, 2.6; H TAA, 2.3) but not at the low dose (L FN, 4.2; L TAA, 4.5). Likewise, values for early morning corrected urinary cortisol/creatinine (nanomoles per mmol) showed significant suppression (P < 0.05) only with high doses of both drugs (PL, 39.0; H FN, 26.5; H TAA, 26.6; L FN, 37.2; L TAA, 36.5). The following conclusions were reached. 1) Overnight and early morning corrected urinary cortisol/creatinine excretion was more sensitive at detecting adrenocortical suppression than basal 0800 h serum cortisol or response to 0.5 microg ACTH stimulation. 2) There were no significant differences between inhaled FN (without spacer) and TAA (with integrated actuator/spacer), which only produced detectable adrenocortical suppression at the highest recommended doses and was not associated with impaired adrenal reserve. 3) Even at the high dose, the suppression observed with both drugs is unlikely to be of clinical relevance.
本研究的目的是评估吸入氟尼缩松(FN)和曲安奈德(TAA)对基础及动态肾上腺皮质活性的影响。采用随机交叉设计,比较安慰剂(PL)、低剂量(L)和高剂量(H)的FN(Aerobid;每喷250微克;无储雾罐;L,1000微克;H,2000微克/天)以及TAA(Azmacort;每喷100微克;带有一体化吸入器/储雾罐;L,800微克;H,1600微克/天)。每种剂量均于08:00和22:00给药,持续3天,各治疗组之间间隔10天的洗脱期。对12名正常志愿者(平均±标准误年龄,24.2±2.4岁)进行了研究。治疗3天后,于08:00(第六次给药后10小时)在促肾上腺皮质激素(ACTH)刺激前采集血样,并在ACTH(0.5微克)刺激后采集血样以测定血清皮质醇。在治疗第三天22:00开始进行过夜以及清晨尿液收集,用于测量经肌酐排泄校正后的尿皮质醇。对于血清皮质醇(ACTH刺激前后),两种药物与安慰剂相比均无显著差异。ACTH刺激后皮质醇(每升纳摩尔数)的值分别为:PL,666.3;高剂量FN,617.0;高剂量TAA,591.4;低剂量FN,699.2;低剂量TAA,686.0。对于过夜经校正的尿皮质醇/肌酐排泄(每毫摩尔纳摩尔数),与PL(6.4)相比,两种药物的高剂量组均有显著抑制(P<0.05)(高剂量FN,2.6;高剂量TAA,2.3),但低剂量组无此现象(低剂量FN,4.2;低剂量TAA,4.5)。同样,清晨经校正的尿皮质醇/肌酐(每毫摩尔纳摩尔数)的值仅在两种药物的高剂量组显示出显著抑制(P<0.05)(PL,39.0;高剂量FN,26.5;高剂量TAA,26.6;低剂量FN,37.2;低剂量TAA,36.5)。得出以下结论。1)过夜和清晨经校正的尿皮质醇/肌酐排泄在检测肾上腺皮质抑制方面比基础08:00时的血清皮质醇或对0.5微克ACTH刺激的反应更敏感。2)吸入的FN(无储雾罐)和TAA(带有一体化吸入器/储雾罐)之间无显著差异,二者仅在最高推荐剂量时产生可检测到的肾上腺皮质抑制,且与肾上腺储备受损无关。3)即使在高剂量时,两种药物观察到的抑制作用也不太可能具有临床相关性。