Koskiniemi M, Van Vleymen B, Hakamies L, Lamusuo S, Taalas J
Haartman Institute, Department of Virology, University of Helsinki, Finland.
J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry. 1998 Mar;64(3):344-8. doi: 10.1136/jnnp.64.3.344.
To compare the efficacy, tolerability, and safety of three daily dosage regimens of oral piracetam in patients with progressive myoclonus epilepsy.
Twenty patients (12 men, eight women), aged 17-43 years, with classical Unverricht-Lundborg disease were enrolled in a multicentre, randomised, double blind trial of crossover design in which the effects of daily doses of 9.6 g, 16.8 g, and 24 g piracetam, given in two divided doses, were compared with placebo. The crossover design was such that patients received placebo and two of the three dosage regimens of piracetam, each for two weeks, for a total treatment period of six weeks and thus without wash out between each treatment phase. The primary outcome measure was a sum score representing the adjusted total of the ratings of six components of a myoclonus rating scale in which stimulus sensitivity, motor impairment, functional disability, handwriting, and global assessments by investigators and patients were scored. Sequential clinical assessments were made by the same neurologist in the same environment at the same time of day.
Treatment with 24 g/day piracetam produced significant and clinically relevant improvement in the primary outcome measure of mean sum score (p=0.005) and in the means of its subtests of motor impairment (p=0.02), functional disability (p=0.003), and in global assessments by both investigator (p=0.002) and patient (p=0.01). Significant improvement in functional disability was also found with daily doses of 9.6 g and 16.8 g. The dose-effect relation was linear and significant. More patients showed clinically relevant improvement with the highest dosage and, in individual patients, increasing the dose improved response. Piracetam was well tolerated and adverse effects were few, mild, and transient.
This study provides further evidence that piracetam is an effective and safe medication in patients with Unverricht-Lundborg disease. In addition, it shows that a dose of 24 g is highly beneficial, more effective than lower doses and that a dose-effect relation exists. There is considerable variation in optimal individual dosage.
比较三种口服吡拉西坦日剂量方案对进行性肌阵挛癫痫患者的疗效、耐受性和安全性。
20例年龄在17至43岁之间、患有典型Unverricht-Lundborg病的患者(12例男性,8例女性),参与了一项多中心、随机、双盲交叉试验,将每日两次给药的9.6 g、16.8 g和24 g吡拉西坦的效果与安慰剂进行比较。交叉设计使得患者接受安慰剂和三种吡拉西坦剂量方案中的两种,每种方案治疗两周,总治疗期为六周,且每个治疗阶段之间无需洗脱期。主要结局指标是一个总和评分,代表肌阵挛评分量表六个组成部分评分的调整总分,其中对刺激敏感性、运动障碍、功能残疾、笔迹以及研究者和患者的整体评估进行评分。由同一位神经科医生在相同环境、每天同一时间进行连续的临床评估。
每日服用24 g吡拉西坦治疗,在主要结局指标平均总和评分方面产生了显著且具有临床意义的改善(p = 0.005),在其运动障碍(p = 0.02)、功能残疾(p = 0.003)子测试的均值方面,以及在研究者(p = 0.002)和患者(p = 0.01)的整体评估方面均有改善。每日剂量为9.6 g和16.8 g时,在功能残疾方面也发现有显著改善。剂量 - 效应关系呈线性且显著。更多患者在最高剂量时显示出具有临床意义的改善,并且在个体患者中,增加剂量可改善反应。吡拉西坦耐受性良好,不良反应少、程度轻且为一过性。
本研究进一步证明吡拉西坦对Unverricht-Lundborg病患者是一种有效且安全的药物。此外,研究表明24 g的剂量非常有益,比低剂量更有效,且存在剂量 - 效应关系。最佳个体剂量存在相当大的差异。