Kocher M S, Gebhardt M C, Mankin H J
Orthopaedic Oncology Service, Massachusetts General Hospital and Harvard Medical School, Boston 02114, USA.
J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1998 Mar;80(3):407-19. doi: 10.2106/00004623-199803000-00014.
Twenty-four patients had reconstruction of the distal aspect of the radius with use of an osteoarticular allograft, between 1974 and 1992, after excision of a giant-cell tumor (twenty patients), a desmoplastic fibroma (two patients), a chondrosarcoma (one patient), or an angiosarcoma (one patient). Nine giant-cell tumors were recurrent lesions, and eleven were extracompartmental primary lesions that had extended through the cortex or subchondral bone. The average age of the patients was 31.5 years (range, fifteen to sixty-one years); thirteen patients were female and eleven were male. Seventeen lesions involved the right wrist and seven involved the left wrist. The reconstruction was performed through a dorsoradial incision with use of a size-matched, preserved, fresh-frozen, distal radial allograft. All procedures included internal fixation and reconstruction of the radiocarpal ligaments. All patients were followed for a minimum of two years (average, 10.9 years; range, 2.1 to 22.3 years). At the time of follow-up, two patients -- one who had a giant-cell tumor and one who had a desmoplastic fibroma -- had a local recurrence. Eight patients needed a revision of the osteoarticular allograft, at an average of 8.1 years (range, 0.8 to 17.8 years) after the initial reconstruction. Seven of these patients had an arthrodesis and one had an amputation. The reason for the revision was a fracture of the allograft in four patients, recurrence of the tumor in one, pain in two, and volar dislocation of the carpus in one. There were fourteen other complications, including ulnocarpal impaction necessitating excision of the distal aspect of the ulna (four), painful hardware necessitating removal (four), rupture of the extensor pollicis longus tendon necessitating transfer of the extensor indicis proprius (two), fracture of the allograft necessitating open reduction and internal fixation (two), volar dislocation of the carpus necessitating closed reduction (one), and a ganglion of the dorsal aspect of the wrist necessitating excision (one). Of the sixteen patients in whom the osteoarticular allograft survived, three did not have pain, nine had pain in association with strenuous activities, and four had pain in association with moderate activities. Three patients reported no functional limitation, nine had limitation in the ability to perform strenuous activities, and four had limitation in the ability to perform moderate activities. The average range of motion of the wrist was 36 degrees of dorsiflexion, 21 degrees of volar flexion, 16 degrees of radial deviation, 15 degrees of ulnar deviation, 58 degrees of supination, and 72 degrees of pronation. Reconstruction of the distal aspect of the radius with use of an osteoarticular allograft was associated with a low rate of recurrence of the tumor, a moderately high rate of revision, little pain in association with common activities, good function, and a moderate range of motion. Osteoarticular allografts are an option for reconstruction of the distal aspect of the radius after excision of a malignant tumor or a recurrent or locally invasive benign lesion.
1974年至1992年间,24例患者在切除骨巨细胞瘤(20例)、促纤维增生性纤维瘤(2例)、软骨肉瘤(1例)或血管肉瘤(1例)后,采用骨关节异体移植重建桡骨远端。9例骨巨细胞瘤为复发病变,11例为突破皮质或软骨下骨的关节外原发性病变。患者的平均年龄为31.5岁(范围为15至61岁);13例为女性,11例为男性。17处病变累及右腕,7处累及左腕。通过背桡侧切口,使用尺寸匹配的、保存的、新鲜冷冻的桡骨远端异体移植进行重建。所有手术均包括内固定和重建桡腕韧带。所有患者至少随访两年(平均10.9年;范围为2.1至22.3年)。在随访时,2例患者——1例患有骨巨细胞瘤,1例患有促纤维增生性纤维瘤——出现局部复发。8例患者需要对骨关节异体移植进行翻修,初次重建后平均8.1年(范围为0.8至17.8年)。其中7例患者进行了关节融合术,1例进行了截肢术。翻修的原因是4例患者异体移植骨折,1例肿瘤复发,2例疼痛,1例腕骨掌侧脱位。还有14例其他并发症,包括尺腕撞击需要切除尺骨远端(4例)、疼痛的内固定物需要取出(4例)、拇长伸肌腱断裂需要示指固有伸肌移位(2例)、异体移植骨折需要切开复位内固定(2例)、腕骨掌侧脱位需要闭合复位(1例)以及腕背侧腱鞘囊肿需要切除(1例)。在骨关节异体移植存活的16例患者中,3例无疼痛,9例在剧烈活动时疼痛,4例在中度活动时疼痛。3例患者报告无功能受限,9例进行剧烈活动的能力受限,4例进行中度活动的能力受限。腕关节的平均活动范围为背伸36度、掌屈21度、桡偏16度、尺偏15度、旋后58度和旋前72度。采用骨关节异体移植重建桡骨远端与肿瘤复发率低、翻修率中等偏高、日常活动时疼痛轻微、功能良好以及活动范围中等有关。骨关节异体移植是切除恶性肿瘤或复发或局部侵袭性良性病变后重建桡骨远端的一种选择。