Yamamoto M, Hara M, Ide M, Ono Y, Jimbo M, Saito I
Department of Neurosurgery, Tokyo Women's Medical College Dai-ni Hospital, Japan.
Surg Neurol. 1998 Apr;49(4):385-97; discussion 397-8. doi: 10.1016/s0090-3019(97)00531-4.
To our knowledge, there are no reported arteriovenous malformation (AVM) series in which detailed long-term follow-up results after radiosurgery were described based on the whole patient group.
We performed a detailed long-term follow-up study of 53 patients with cerebral AVMs treated with gamma knife (GK) radiosurgery, with emphasis on radiation-related adverse effects detected on neuro-imaging after a long post-irradiation latency period (3-10 years). The post-GK follow-up period was 40-232 months excluding two mortalities, the mean being 112 and the median being 111 months.
Three patients (5.6%) have, as yet, refused all neuro-imaging follow-up studies. Complete nidus obliteration was confirmed angiographically in 32 patients (60.4%) between 1 and 5 post-GK years. In the other 18 patients (34%), despite significant nidus shrinkage being angiographically demonstrated, complete obliteration was not achieved during a 2-7 year follow-up period. There were two mortalities, one AVM-related (massive re-bleeding during the latency period) and the other angiography-related. There were five radiation-related morbidities (9.4%), three of which-hemi-Parkinson syndrome, hemiparesis, and visual field disturbances attributable to delayed cyst formation-manifested at 5.5, 7 and 7 post-GK years, respectively. We also experienced five patients (9.4%) in whom, despite remaining asymptomatic to date, radiation-related adverse effects were seen on neuro-imaging: middle cerebral artery stenosis at 3 post-GK years in one patient; dural arteriovenous fistula at 7 post GK-years in one; delayed cyst formation in two, at 5 and 10 post-GK years; and a small cavitation at 9 post-GK years.
Long-term follow-up, particularly with neuro-imaging modalities, is essential even after the "treatment goal" has been attained.
据我们所知,尚无基于整个患者群体描述放射外科手术后详细长期随访结果的动静脉畸形(AVM)系列报道。
我们对53例接受伽玛刀(GK)放射外科治疗的脑动静脉畸形患者进行了详细的长期随访研究,重点关注在较长的照射后潜伏期(3 - 10年)后神经影像学检查发现的与辐射相关的不良反应。排除两例死亡病例后,GK术后随访期为40 - 232个月,平均为112个月,中位数为111个月。
三名患者(5.6%)至今拒绝所有神经影像学随访研究。32例患者(60.4%)在GK术后1至5年经血管造影证实畸形巢完全闭塞。在其他18例患者(34%)中,尽管血管造影显示畸形巢明显缩小,但在2至7年的随访期内未实现完全闭塞。有两例死亡,一例与AVM相关(潜伏期大量再出血),另一例与血管造影相关。有五例与辐射相关的并发症(9.4%),其中三例——偏侧帕金森综合征、偏瘫和因延迟囊肿形成导致的视野障碍——分别在GK术后5.5年、7年和7年出现。我们还发现五例患者(9.4%),尽管目前无症状,但神经影像学检查发现了与辐射相关的不良反应:一名患者在GK术后3年出现大脑中动脉狭窄;一名患者在GK术后7年出现硬脑膜动静脉瘘;两名患者分别在GK术后5年和10年出现延迟囊肿形成;一名患者在GK术后9年出现小空洞形成。
即使在达到“治疗目标”后,长期随访,尤其是神经影像学检查,仍然至关重要。